Hi, chapos. I posted this in the check-in thread and was recommended to make a post about it so here it is:
In a queer space recently, I met a lesbian lady who lives in Pakistan and works for the Department of School Education. Direct quotes:
"I work with the School Education Department, which approaches the children who live in remote areas on those living in the triol areas, for schooling, we make our small schools in it, which means for some time in one area, then for some time in another area, these areas tribals are against the education of girls, then in these areas. It works"
For like two seconds I thought this was cool, but she started talking about how "the tribals" in Punjab are all "dangerous" and "keep their girls from going to school", and how the Department delivers USAID textbooks, uniforms, so on. Smelt really bad to me, particularly the use of the noun "tribals" and automatic connection of them to misogyny and violence:
Direct Quote 2: "There are many tribal areas in Pakistan, there are hilly areas where there is a tribal who is the chief, they are ruled or there are organizations, then they themselves hold the community there, people are not allowed to send girls out of the house or send them to school, especially when the girl is above 10 years of age. So sheis not allowed to go out of the house, it is considered worse to go to school."
Direct quote 3: "Yes, the department also supports a little bit and gives its own people such as Wellingly who want to go and in addition to this, USAID also helps in it, free books free uniforms things, etc."
I heavily suspect that this is an imperialist thing. Pakistan has been somewhat in the USA's pocket for a while from what I can tell, and USAID funded/written? textbooks were also what the Taliban used in Afghanistan for radicalisation, based on what I could dig up. I also discovered that there's been debate about the content of textbooks which I suspect is related. Westoid search results make it hard to draw connections :)
Certainly there is criticism of USAID regarding corruption and such, and Pakistan does not seem to treat its tribespeople very well. They've also sent their military into the FATA region with the excuse of "antiterrorism operations", which sounds great.
Worthy to note, I just asked her about what she does and how it gets done, I did not unhinge my jaw and spew forth a DOG OF THE USAMERICAN EMPIRE rant, because you know what they say about No Investigation. It was kind of surreal to be trying to sniff out potential western propaganda in realtime while talking with this queer woman from Pakistan though. This whole thing, this lesbian woman bitching and griping ahout THOSE TRIBALS who DONT WANT THEIR GIRLS EDUMACATED whilst working for a US-funded state education department fucking reeks of pinkwashing.
Opinions from anyone educated or knowledgeable on this subject are greatly appreciated, especially if we have any comrades from Pakistan
season 4 of blowback talks a lot about the Afghan-Pakistan region. fun fact: the line between Pakistan and Afghanistan, a completely imaginary line drawn by a British Civil Servant named Mortimer in 1898 has never been recognized by the people in the area.
if i recall correctly, though afghanistan was struggling to cast off feudal past much like the people of the czarist russian empire, it had the beginnings of a socialist movement by the time of the revolution. afghanistan was the first country to recognize the Bolshevik government. pakistan, though fully breaking off from india post british-raj was still a political project with deeply entrenched connections between their elites, intelligence services, and their anglosphere counterparts. the pakistan side of the eventual durand line was used as a site to amass people and materials for empowering and protecting the opium gangsters that fueled the Opium Wars which had made many british lords / East India Company very wealthy. in the cold war era, it was again used to re-establish connections to the entrenched warlords that had birthed in the manure of those gangsters and their opium wealth. another fun fact: pakistan got to be site of the bank that funded western sponsored terrorism. it's really critical to remember that during this era of the cold war (1970s), the US/UK was militarily allied with Pakistan, Turkey, Iran, and Iraq. it was literally called the Bhagdad Pact.
these gangsters with their fiefdoms HATED what socialism/communism represented and routinely issued public death threats to women politicians (the only women politicians in afghanistan were communists, of course) and engaged in political violence to intimidate and murder them and eventually anyone who supported women's rights. they were of course naturally approached by the CIA to partner up against the soviet neighbors. i believe in a single year with CIA support and training, these monsters and their private militias burned out 1500 schools just for the crime of teaching literacy to girls/women. this and the sponsoring of incursions into the USSR was an untold part of the lead up to the soviet invasion of afghanistan for me.
there's more details in the episodes about dates, times, events, and individuals... but anyone who claims the tribal areas of Afganistan-Pakistan and their reactionary features are not a direct product of british colonialism and hardcore cold war anglosphere meddling is ignorant.
on a more personal note, i have never met anyone associated with USAID that didn't have insanely racist / US state department brainworms, with memory holes where there should be knowledge of historical events.
This is precisely the answer I was looking for, everything I expected and more. Opium-Wars gangster guys that hated socialism and women's rights,vuddying up with the CIA to destroy schools and attack the USSR! Glad to know I wasn't far off. The reasons to listen to Blowback are mounting as well.
On a more personal note, that's the "vibe" I was getting too from this interaction. Thank you for the informative & complete reply!