Revolutionary Defeatism means fighting against the empires you are within to defeat them from within, such as the Bolsheviks did in WW1. You do Revolutionary Defeatism within imperialist nations during imperialist wars.
So by saying you support revolutionary defeatism in Russia right now, what that effectively means is that you believe Russia’s government is doing an imperialist war and should be overthrown. It should not be. Revolutionary Defeatism is not the correct tactic for Russian anti-imperialists right now
Just like a current revolt in Russia would be NATO backed reactionaries
So shut the fuck up and analyze the real conditions not the ones in your head. Don’t advocate for revolution before we are ready. This is dangerous, childish IDEALISM
You do realize they have to bomb Kharkiv to achieve victory right? Out one side of your mouth you say you agree, then you contradict out the other. Then you get mad and attack those pointing out your incoherence
deleted by creator
Revolutionary Defeatism means fighting against the empires you are within to defeat them from within, such as the Bolsheviks did in WW1. You do Revolutionary Defeatism within imperialist nations during imperialist wars.
So by saying you support revolutionary defeatism in Russia right now, what that effectively means is that you believe Russia’s government is doing an imperialist war and should be overthrown. It should not be. Revolutionary Defeatism is not the correct tactic for Russian anti-imperialists right now
deleted by creator
So you WOULD back a color revolution in Russia during the operation of an anti-imperialist war. Thank you for confirming your Liberalism.
Removed by mod
You would support the overthrow of “rightwing capitalist imperialist” Assad during the middle of the Civil War. That’s how idealist you are
deleted by creator
But it wasn’t. It was NATO backed jihadists.
Just like a current revolt in Russia would be NATO backed reactionaries
So shut the fuck up and analyze the real conditions not the ones in your head. Don’t advocate for revolution before we are ready. This is dangerous, childish IDEALISM
deleted by creator
Swift Russian victory will have the least deaths yes. They should push onward quickly
deleted by creator
You don’t agree, you want Russia to collapse right now and for the war to lose morale
deleted by creator
Both of you please disengage
deleted by creator
You are not thinking dialectically, just making moralist and idealist spasms
Both of you please disengage
Removed by mod
deleted by creator
You do realize they have to bomb Kharkiv to achieve victory right? Out one side of your mouth you say you agree, then you contradict out the other. Then you get mad and attack those pointing out your incoherence
deleted by creator
Removed by mod
deleted by creator
deleted by creator
Yes I think you are actually a dumbass baby ultra
deleted by creator