Socialist states should just start calling them editorially independent while being the ultimate appointers of the leadership who decide that "editing".
With a structure like the current BBC (minus the BBC Trust that used to regulate it) the organisation becomes a mouthpiece of the state by virtue of being filled top to bottom with ideologically chosen people and a leadership carrying out a specific mission.
I am leaning towards the argument that the defining thing that matters is whether it is under proletarian or bourgeoise control. Under proletarian control the BBC would become a mouthpiece of the proletarian state within 5 years of reorganisation from the top down.
The argument socialists have against doing this kind of thing is that the capitalist world would still claim it's state-controlled, but I see very little reason not to do at least to expose bullshit when there are no downsides given the outcome would likely not be different to the existing orgs.
Socialist states should just start calling them editorially independent while being the ultimate appointers of the leadership who decide that "editing".
With a structure like the current BBC (minus the BBC Trust that used to regulate it) the organisation becomes a mouthpiece of the state by virtue of being filled top to bottom with ideologically chosen people and a leadership carrying out a specific mission.
I am leaning towards the argument that the defining thing that matters is whether it is under proletarian or bourgeoise control. Under proletarian control the BBC would become a mouthpiece of the proletarian state within 5 years of reorganisation from the top down.
The argument socialists have against doing this kind of thing is that the capitalist world would still claim it's state-controlled, but I see very little reason not to do at least to expose bullshit when there are no downsides given the outcome would likely not be different to the existing orgs.
It would at least be nice to be able to come back with “CGTN has literally the exact same organizational structure as the BBC”