Yeah my b :shrug-outta-hecks: I try not to be sectarian and there is a lot of anarchist theory I agree with, but to call Makhnovshchina the only example of socialism is preposterous because they didn't control their own industrial production, survived military conflicts due to the larger engagement of the whites and reds, and were too disorganized on a larger scale to ever stand as a stable state, much less a truly socialist one, in the face of encroaching capitalist powers.