• Justice@lemmygrad.ml
    ·
    4 months ago

    TLDR: massive digression incoming. Hardly related to the comment section linked

    My doctor has recommended I start punching myself in the face 3 times upon waking up because it causes less injury to my brain than scrolling across this shit...

    Someone in those comments linked a site I haven't seen in a long time:

    "Rationalwiki"

    First thought is "oh, that right winger site from a decade+ ago??? Being posted by fake, but self-declared, "leftists"???"

    I don't know if it's still a far right wing site, or if I confused it with another similarly named site

    But I did it give it the ol' test search. None better than Israel

    Although once an ancient Bible-era civilization, Israel ceased to exist after being conquered by various empires and only re-emerged as a sovereign entity in 1948.

    Weird framing citing Biblical sources. If you're citing the Bible or any other religious texts, you are objectively not being rational... on rationalwiki.

    Israel is involved in numerous international disputes and conflicts, partially arising from religious hostility towards it and partially arising from Israel's own aggressive and oppressive behavior. One of those disputes concerns where exactly Israel's capital really is. Most of the world recognizes the city of Tel Aviv, but Israel itself claims the city of Jerusalem as its capital and has most of its government located there. A lot of stress also arises because Israel was built on the land that many Palestinians used to live on and Israel currently occupies Palestinian territory. The Muslim-majority Palestinians demand their own state and want Israel to stop its oppressive treatment of them. Israel also militarily occupies the Golan Heights region of Syria and is regularly in conflict with Palestinian liberation/terrorist groups.

    Bold emphasis mine. Citing the essentially irrelevant religious hostility towards Israel (or Jews, as the framing would prefer) is... frankly, a dark joke at this point in the genocide. There is no real, observable hatred for Israelis as Jews for being practicing adherents of Judaism from Palestinian Muslims or Christians. There is all the hatred for the military apparatus, state government and all those Israelis who support the ongoing blockade, land theft, murder, torture, genocide.

    And you can't list all these grievances against a people then call their liberation groups liberation SLASH* terrorist. It's one or the other. The Israeli government and its allies US, UK, etc. have chosen to frame all Palestinian liberation efforts as terrorism. Should a RATIONAL wiki be adopting or parroting the stances, uncritically, of the most powerful nations on earth? I dunno. Seems a bit irrational to me.

    Complicating the problem is that Hamas and certain of Israel's neighbors don't want Israel to exist, so they have a habit of launching rockets at it once in a while.

    Oh, that's the only reason why? Or even a significant reason? Not the constant oppression and murder (pre-Oct 2023) of Palestinians in Gaza and Jerusalem. Ok. Just they hate the smollest bwean Isweweal. Mweanies! 🥺

    Fuck reddit. I know this was a massive digression, but I fell down a rabbit hole and, well, I love dragging people with me. Wikipedia is ok for understanding some very basic facts and definitions. Probably this rationalwiki is the same on many topics. It's Israel page that I was ripping my own hair out over above is, and it's unfortunate that this is true, more objective and more historically "true" than most narratives you'll find in western MSM. It still couldn't help both sidesing a settler-colonial project, ethnic cleansing, and genocide though.

    Maybe they think if you just start correctly ripping into Israel's ass it wouldn't be fair. And they're right. It wouldn't be fair because you end up with basically 100% of the evil bad stuff on only one side, Israel's. So they go with false bullshit about "well, maybe Palestinians stole the land 6000 years ago so...!" Ok. And "well, Palestinians got really mad and started killing Israelis and launching rockets!... after we stole their land and killed a bunch of their people." Ok. There's just no rational argument for framing anything Israel does as justified because it simply isn't.

    This "wiki" (on Israel anyway) is just editorialized bullshit seemingly crafted to tweak the nipples of liberal Zionists who love Israel, don't give a shit about Palestinians, and just secretly wish Israel could kinda "hurry up" with the whole genocide thing so they can go back to never speaking about it again or, in their dreams, never hearing leftist protesters "whining" about it again.