Its genuinely quite shit

• Game doesn't run on a 4080 super and doesn't even look good enough to warrant the performance it looks like any copy paste unreal 5 dreck. Frame pacing is all over the place so even high and capped framerates feel awful
• UI may as well be from far cry completely misses the aspect of what made the original games interface so good
• stealth is broken enemies see you from miles away through foliage then aimbot your brain and has that stupid 360 degree ubisoft enemy can see you ring that i hate
• mutants eat bullets makes bloodsuckers frustrating rather than scary
• game has forced on mouse accell and smoothing with no option to disable without messing in the configs
• no muzzle flash lighting or shadows cast from the torch which were very big features of the original game
• buttons don't register sometimes and need to be pressed twice weather this is to open or close inventory/pda or even worse to fucking quicksave where many times i realised it didn't save at all cos i have to press it twice
• difficulty modes copy modern game difficulty make you weaker and enemies bullet sponges and has nothing similar to the original trilogies master difficulty
• first encounter with a poltergeist went terribly unlike in shoc where you meet one in that bunker and it ynow levitates the object then throws it to give you time to identify and move.... This one the physics object moves AFTER IT HITS YOU so you only see it reacting BOUNCING OFF YOUR BODY and they are impossible to avoid like completely aimbot buckets
• english va is somehow worse than in the originals
• its made by nazis
• a-life 2.0 is reported currently as broken so its just a random enemy spawner ring around the player which is another significant staple of the original games
• stupid animations for inventory and PDA that really don't need to exist and just get in the way
• Even breaking open crates for stuff feels bad the model just disappears into a few particle effects rather than ynow actually falls apart into physics objects like the fucking original games managed to do
• fuzzy ass image like every fuzzy ass UE5 game

Positives:

• guns sound nice and have good animations

If ur getting the game pirate the gog version but its not worth it just play the originals. The design language adopted for this game was to make it more like a ubisoft game than take what made the originals so impactful.

I got the list above from the prologue i didn't need to play anything else