I came across this thread which had some interesting interpretations and posits that ML grew as a function of anarchism's failure to recruit/organize:

My sincere answer for why tankies reemerged five years ago is that movements are social hierarchies and newbie teens don't want to compete for status in existing illegible/inaccessible spaces like anarchism, so they resurrected a dead/empty scene that had trappings of status.

See also leftypol & the dirtbaggers. Folks get converted on one issue and then recoil about being expected to also learn / change their opinion on a variety of other topics. Respecting pronouns?! Never! You olds are a joke! We're making a new movement with hookers & blackjack!

Most of the anarchist movement had sneered at and avoided the internet (seen as an insecure tool of civilized alienation). Also it was illegible, most of the shit we expect you to learn/accept we don't even write down. And getting involved? We're terrible at helping folks join.

But ALSO the anarchist movement got up its own ass. We derided the internet and avoided utilizing it effectively. We embraced illegibility as resistance, forgetting that accessibility is critical to undermining hierarchies. And we corrupted into playing internal status games.

So what do we ascribe the sudden uptick in radicalization?

  • a_jug_of_marx_piss [he/him]
    ·
    4 years ago

    Most of the interpretation seems kind of garbage. Like, assuming that people "converted on one issue and then recoil about being expected to also learn / change their opinion on a variety of other topics", how would that make them end up as tankies? Surely, ML is just as far if not further from most people's ideologies as anarchism? Apparently, you don't need to know anything to be a tankie, you just need to be status-driven, authoritarian and bloodthirsty.

    It's pretty easy to end up under the illusion that you arrived at your current ideology through being rational, and that somebody not in the same place must have something wrong with them. This should obviously be avoided, seeming up your own ass like this guy is one of the better consequences of it.