r/stupidpol has been infamous on this site and on the sub for a while, and for good reason. I decided to make an effortpost on why I personally dislike them, and explain how they could fix their shit.

  1. They don't post actual stupid identity politics On the surface, a sub making fun of woke politics of liberals seems like a good idea. But r/stpidpol rarely does that. What do I mean?

An example of identity politics being used in a stupid way would be the NYT calling bernie a sexist while praising Bloomberg, people denouncing Marxism as "racist," or neolibs and "rainbow capitalism," ie, female drone pilots.

Their biggest problem is that they don't focus on shit that matters. For instance, recently, they talked about how the University of Michigan banned some words that were, well, stupid. For example, they banned "brown bag," which is dumb as fuck. But this isn't a serious issue, imo. Some university banning the word "slave" isn't really a pressing societal issue.

Or, often, they will mock some leftist subs for banning words LIKE stupid, which I agree is... stupid - but that doesn't mean we shouldn't have a discussion about it.

I'll often see the stupidpol types fall into the same traps that far-right people do, being overly sensationalist about small stuff.

  1. They are often reactionary Today, one of the top posts is from a website literally called "The American Conservative." I've seen dozens of people who have flairs saying "Nazbol" and "Strasserist," or "Conservative." They label any LGBTQ content "soft queer shit," and one time, while discussing more teens becoming LGBTQ, mocked it and belittled it (LGBTQ Issues). They once said that Taxi Driver, a movie that the director has called a feminist film, and which is very obviously a deconstruction of the effects of a misogynistic and toxicly masculine culture, is actually just about a war vet and mocked tumblr for even thinking that the movie could have feminist undertones.

Also, there 3rd most overlapped subreddit is some anti-sjw sub.

  1. They aren't socialists The leftists that you do see on the sub are almost always social democrat bernie types, and they seem to have a massive hardon for Bernie. I love Bernie, but he isn't the greatest thing ever, and they make him out to be that way. i've seen almost no leftcoms, anarchists, MLs,, or any actual leftists, and a higher percentage of rightists.

Finally, they aren't edgy. They like to pretend they are, but their humor boils down to the same crap that rightists use. The n word, sexism, etc.

And any time they try and say we're the PC, safe, sanitized ones, remind them that our subs were the ones that got banned, not theirs.