I mean you can definitely get good bagels elsewhere that have been boiled before baking, one of the specific things about bagels in NYC is the specific level of the water hardness that makes for an ideally textured bagel. This could absolutely be done artificially with water softeners or by adding minerals, but NYC is already there. Too soft of water and it gets goopy, too hard and the gluten gets super stiff.
I mean you can definitely get good bagels elsewhere that have been boiled before baking, one of the specific things about bagels in NYC is the specific level of the water hardness that makes for an ideally textured bagel. This could absolutely be done artificially with water softeners or by adding minerals, but NYC is already there. Too soft of water and it gets goopy, too hard and the gluten gets super stiff.