Marx was ethnically Jewish he can have any opinion he wants about Jewish people. Anyone that brings it up always fucking leaves out the fact he is speaking about his own people.
It's pretty critical information. There's a huge difference between a white person saying a bunch of problematic shit about black people and a black person saying a bunch of problematic shit about black people. One is racism, the other is deeply engrained brainworms.
It completely changes the way you interpret a situation.
I'd dispute the relevance of this. He wasn't raised Jewish, I'm not even sure if he knew of his Jewish ancestry. His parents converted and he lived and died as the son of Lutherans.
In Prussia Jews had an unequal status. When the Rhineland was taken this meant jews there could no longer serve as lawyers, judges, civil servants, university lecturers or schoolteachers – unless they converted to Christianity.
Marx's father was affected by this. They converted through coercion, not desire.
There is absolutely no way Marx was not aware of this. Or the fact his grandparents were Rabbis. How would you not know what your grandparents do or did during their lives? You'd have to be incredibly disconnected from your family for that information to just disappear in 2 generations.
His grandfather was Rabbiner, his grandfather's father was Rabbiner, his uncle was Rabbiner, his wife's father was Rabbiner, he put his son to rest on a Jewish graveyard... obviously he was aware of his Jewish ancestry.
Marx was ethnically Jewish he can have any opinion he wants about Jewish people. Anyone that brings it up always fucking leaves out the fact he is speaking about his own people.
deleted by creator
It's pretty critical information. There's a huge difference between a white person saying a bunch of problematic shit about black people and a black person saying a bunch of problematic shit about black people. One is racism, the other is deeply engrained brainworms.
It completely changes the way you interpret a situation.
I'd dispute the relevance of this. He wasn't raised Jewish, I'm not even sure if he knew of his Jewish ancestry. His parents converted and he lived and died as the son of Lutherans.
In Prussia Jews had an unequal status. When the Rhineland was taken this meant jews there could no longer serve as lawyers, judges, civil servants, university lecturers or schoolteachers – unless they converted to Christianity.
Marx's father was affected by this. They converted through coercion, not desire.
There is absolutely no way Marx was not aware of this. Or the fact his grandparents were Rabbis. How would you not know what your grandparents do or did during their lives? You'd have to be incredibly disconnected from your family for that information to just disappear in 2 generations.
deleted by creator
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/de/thumb/4/4f/MarxA.jpg/1600px-MarxA.jpg
His grandfather was Rabbiner, his grandfather's father was Rabbiner, his uncle was Rabbiner, his wife's father was Rabbiner, he put his son to rest on a Jewish graveyard... obviously he was aware of his Jewish ancestry.