The show is pure Barney the Dinosaur mentality. Everyone is friends and gets along, and sometimes when there are real issues that COULD have material impact on people, they just get resolved by people saying the right words and everyone being friends. Unless there is a serious course-correction and the writers have just done a bad job of progressing through plotlines after setting the table, then the moral of the show is that performative sensitivity and pointing out things like "colonialism" are on their own good enough to make things better.

If you aren't aware, the premise is Jason Sudoku from SNL (he played Biden in 08!) is an (American) college football coach who gets hired to coach (soccer) futbol on Nonce Island. This premise is pretty interesting because college football coaches are all literal psychopaths, and the idea of one trying to coach soccer is genuinely funny. The first season was maybe not as bad in hindsight as the show has gotten, but it was short and I watched it all basically in a day out of boredom (this show is EXTREMELY popular among football/sports media people).

Anyways, season 2 has some of the pieces for interesting conflict along class/racial/economic lines, but all the people are friends and friendship is the best so the problems get solved offscreen. Also, the dialogue is 99% soy banter and like, Family Guy style obscure reference humor but coming from a guy who really WANTS to be Mister Rogers. And some people do SWEARS, so it's definitely not for babies! But if you took them out it would be!

If this show is as influential as some people think, then I fear it is only a matter of time before the cheap network clones roll out a thousand worse versions of this and liberals talk about how great it is over brunch while nothing gets meaningfully done. Any sort of progressive ideals or "difficult topics" are 100% there performatively. I think Felix would put this much better than I did, so hopefully we get a "This is Sus" special.

  • cumslutlenin [he/him]
    ·
    3 years ago

    I watched the first two episodes with my wife and had to feel like a heartless asshole because I didn't like it. I even like Jason Sudeikis and Juno Temple and Septa Unella, but the jokes were painfully unfunny and there weren't a lot of them, just live-action Ned Flanders coming in with hot ones like "tea tastes like garbage water."

    What drives me nuts about this kind of show in general is that its fans moralise it so much, and they all use the same talking points. "It's just what we need now!" "Isn't a show about kindness and empathy more important now than ever?" "I guess I'm just supposed to like mean depressing shows, then!" I don't understand why they all feel so threatened when the show has like 99% critical approval ratings and is only now starting to get some pushback.

    (Other factors in my dislike for this show: I don't like rom-coms that much, I think 40 minutes is an absurd length for a sitcom episode, I showed my wife The Damned United once and she didn't like it)