People who make that sort of argument are thinking something like:
Past - people work full time jobs just to feed and shelter themselves
Now - people work full time jobs just to feed and shelter themselves, but now they have smart phones, refrigerators, a wider variety of foods, etc
So the now is strictly better.
Now personally I think that if anyone is struggling to feed themselves then that is a full scale moral crisis that must be dealt with. But someone who's comfortable enough to have never experienced that might not understand the gravity of the situation. And even if they have, people as a whole are just loaded with ways to accept and gloss over huge bad things in our world.
...But also, while the person supporting the progress of the modern world might be talking about smartphones and trinkets, I want to point out that Kropotkin wrote before the Green Revolution and we still don't have the free bread he was talking about.
"Now is strictly better" is, I guess, TECHNICALLY true... But yeah man talk about totally missing the point...
Thanks for phrasing it like that though - I can definitely see how it could be someone who just is unaware of the situations of others instead of strictly being something used by trolls.
People who make that sort of argument are thinking something like:
Past - people work full time jobs just to feed and shelter themselves
Now - people work full time jobs just to feed and shelter themselves, but now they have smart phones, refrigerators, a wider variety of foods, etc
So the now is strictly better.
Now personally I think that if anyone is struggling to feed themselves then that is a full scale moral crisis that must be dealt with. But someone who's comfortable enough to have never experienced that might not understand the gravity of the situation. And even if they have, people as a whole are just loaded with ways to accept and gloss over huge bad things in our world.
...But also, while the person supporting the progress of the modern world might be talking about smartphones and trinkets, I want to point out that Kropotkin wrote before the Green Revolution and we still don't have the free bread he was talking about.
"Now is strictly better" is, I guess, TECHNICALLY true... But yeah man talk about totally missing the point...
Thanks for phrasing it like that though - I can definitely see how it could be someone who just is unaware of the situations of others instead of strictly being something used by trolls.
deleted by creator