It's more like "the country that currently exists here and the country we're trying to build here have so little in common that using symbols of the former to represent the latter would be peculiar." Although, optics-wise, I have no idea whether that's actually better.
Not that you can’t discuss changing these symbols and stuff, but foaming at the mouth at them this hard every single time when nobody else does that, especially not working people who’ve got more to worry about, is just weird.
This shit shows you fundamentally do not understand the UK. If the English flag is seen outside of sporting events it is assumed by pretty much everyone that that person is a racist gammon. It is synonymous with racism, the EDL and white supremacy. The majority of the UK finds flag shagging somewhat embarrassing at the best of times, let alone when it's specifically chosen flag shagging as a means of white virtue signalling.
The people that claim "English heritage" are white people that do not see anyone other than white anglos as English.
Are you from the UK? Or is this an american perspective? Because that would make sense given how fucking normalised flag shagging is over there. It's deeply embarrassing shit and a very large number of people elsewhere in the world cringe when they see people doing it.
Fuck off patsoc. Go somewhere else and defend american communists waving the american flag, it's the same fucking thing. Seriously do not want to receive another message from you. Period.
What people do you think waving the English flag is "getting on their side" ? And what people do you think it is alienating to? Given its usage outside of sports is regarded as racism.
I'll ask you again. Who do you think the people waving this flag define as "English" ?
but you can’t do it by calling the people who use them racist when they only use them because it represents their country and they’re not even thinking of the bad things it might symbolize
I don't think you quite understand how thoroughly the English flag is used to represent "England for the English" type of rhetoric. Outside of the sports context (the only justified use of it today) the people waving the English flag rather than the union jack are doing so to intentionally make a statement about being white, it is utilised in all cases as a dogwhistle for anglo-white English racism.
This is why "Who do you define as English?" is such an important question here. I guarantee you that someone with afro-caribbean ethnicity (quite common in the UK) or indian or pakistan ethnicity, but born in England, is not considered "real English" to the people who fly this flag. I stress the outside of sports part here.
i get you're well meaning, but outside of a major sporting event, it is seen as about the same level of far-right scumfuckery as the yank confederate flag
and i live in one of the poorest parts of the country
Yes, and that was during the period of time the other poster was referring to
It's just funny how Euros constantly call us morons for not knowing history and yet suddenly someone can come up with a hilarious misnomer like "Confederate Yankee" and they thinks they're the one that's right.
You see, the thing is that the English flag isn't actually used for anything other than sports. The Union Jack is used as the flag of the country, because the country is the United Kingdom.
This is what creates the unique usage of the English flag by racists.
This isn't something that is just an "internet forum" thing either. This is in the mainstream discussion regularly, year after year after year.
The Youth Communist League has made zero comment about Parliament stepping in front of Scottish Parliament rulings. I know very little about them (other than what I can gather from scrolling through their official social media) so on the ground activists may be a different issue, but I can imagine that it might be alienating to have this group that's going on about the importance of English patriotism after not saying shit about Parliament obstructing devolved powers.
well if their issue is with the union between scotland and england so I would assume that they would find the british flag more offensive as that is the flag specifically symbolising that
St george is the patron saint of England and Palestine I see no harm in celebrating the day
deleted by creator
It's more like "the country that currently exists here and the country we're trying to build here have so little in common that using symbols of the former to represent the latter would be peculiar." Although, optics-wise, I have no idea whether that's actually better.
deleted by creator
This shit shows you fundamentally do not understand the UK. If the English flag is seen outside of sporting events it is assumed by pretty much everyone that that person is a racist gammon. It is synonymous with racism, the EDL and white supremacy. The majority of the UK finds flag shagging somewhat embarrassing at the best of times, let alone when it's specifically chosen flag shagging as a means of white virtue signalling.
The people that claim "English heritage" are white people that do not see anyone other than white anglos as English.
Are you from the UK? Or is this an american perspective? Because that would make sense given how fucking normalised flag shagging is over there. It's deeply embarrassing shit and a very large number of people elsewhere in the world cringe when they see people doing it.
deleted by creator
You should ask yourself who the people waving this flag define as "English".
deleted by creator
Fuck off patsoc. Go somewhere else and defend american communists waving the american flag, it's the same fucking thing. Seriously do not want to receive another message from you. Period.
deleted by creator
You are those people
deleted by creator
:england-cool: :england-cool: :england-cool: :england-cool: :england-cool:
deleted by creator
What people do you think waving the English flag is "getting on their side" ? And what people do you think it is alienating to? Given its usage outside of sports is regarded as racism.
I'll ask you again. Who do you think the people waving this flag define as "English" ?
deleted by creator
I don't think you quite understand how thoroughly the English flag is used to represent "England for the English" type of rhetoric. Outside of the sports context (the only justified use of it today) the people waving the English flag rather than the union jack are doing so to intentionally make a statement about being white, it is utilised in all cases as a dogwhistle for anglo-white English racism.
This is why "Who do you define as English?" is such an important question here. I guarantee you that someone with afro-caribbean ethnicity (quite common in the UK) or indian or pakistan ethnicity, but born in England, is not considered "real English" to the people who fly this flag. I stress the outside of sports part here.
deleted by creator
i get you're well meaning, but outside of a major sporting event, it is seen as about the same level of far-right scumfuckery as the yank confederate flag
and i live in one of the poorest parts of the country
deleted by creator
i'm talking about the flag to be clear
deleted by creator
Imagine calling the Confederates Yankees
:data-laughing:
all americans are yanks :shrug-outta-hecks:
They literally seceded and thus, weren't Americans
What, is there some kind of crippling shortage of vocabulary for racists in your country?
:michael-laugh:
the only people who care about the american definition are yanks
Removed by mod
:farquaad-point: yank
deleted by creator
Yes, and that was during the period of time the other poster was referring to
It's just funny how Euros constantly call us morons for not knowing history and yet suddenly someone can come up with a hilarious misnomer like "Confederate Yankee" and they thinks they're the one that's right.
You see, the thing is that the English flag isn't actually used for anything other than sports. The Union Jack is used as the flag of the country, because the country is the United Kingdom.
This is what creates the unique usage of the English flag by racists.
This isn't something that is just an "internet forum" thing either. This is in the mainstream discussion regularly, year after year after year.
Here's a bunch of racists talking down a black man raising issues about this topic. Reminder that Farage is known to have drawn the National Front logo on all his schoolbooks in school so his reference to them in argument here is telling.
And we don't just have this discussion about the English flag, but the Union Jack too
I'm fucking bored of it to be honest I could dig up something that refers to this discussion year after year after year. But it is what it is...
EDIT: Fuck it here's another for you
In london sure in the countryside the english flag is just a fairly common symbol that doesn't mean much
deleted by creator
The issue isn't the day itself.
Removed by mod
Can you fucking read?
deleted by creator
I am in several orgs. Lick my taint. You're the one that COMPLETELY MISREAD the above comment.
deleted by creator
:pigpoop:
deleted by creator
And how is shagging the English flag not alienating to say, Scottish comrades who only this year saw parliament clamp down on Scottish sovereignty?
deleted by creator
The Youth Communist League has made zero comment about Parliament stepping in front of Scottish Parliament rulings. I know very little about them (other than what I can gather from scrolling through their official social media) so on the ground activists may be a different issue, but I can imagine that it might be alienating to have this group that's going on about the importance of English patriotism after not saying shit about Parliament obstructing devolved powers.
well if their issue is with the union between scotland and england so I would assume that they would find the british flag more offensive as that is the flag specifically symbolising that
It literally has the Cross of St. George in it
yes and the cross of st Andrew and some other lines to symbolise northern Ireland. The flag was designed by James the 6th of Scotland
:PIGPOOPBALLS: