good post

https://twitter.com/BadEmpanada/status/1661212920938737665

  • Huldra [they/them, it/its]
    ·
    1 year ago

    https://redsails.org/masses-elites-and-rebels/

    Brainwashing is a two way process, if brainwashing is accepted as an excuse for participation in genocidal wars, theres obvious gain in playing along with it and claiming you were just brainwashed.

    • Huldra [they/them, it/its]
      ·
      edit-2
      1 year ago

      Also I am fucking better than that kid, because I've never killed anyone.

      I have not been in whatever hypothetical material condition this hypothetical kid was in, but I belive I could trust myself to not take blood money in exchange for participation in imperialism.

      Not because of some strawman genetical superiority, but because I think thats a matter of basic morals and solidarity. And if I did take take the blood money in this situation, I would deserve repercussions from that.

          • aaro [they/them, she/her]
            ·
            1 year ago

            I get that you're not being serious here but this is exactly what I mean. They had a different mommy. Maybe they were abused and only learned to influence their surroundings through violence. Maybe the truest love they'd ever felt was the pride of their parents for believing the same lies. Almost certainly they had the un-humanity of the Other drilled into their head harder than it was drilled in to yours or mine.

            • Huldra [they/them, it/its]
              ·
              1 year ago

              I will simply not be excusing genocide.

              If you are going to reply to this with further sob story hypotheticals, simply do not, fuck off instead.

              • aaro [they/them, she/her]
                ·
                edit-2
                1 year ago

                look comrade, I have literally already - in a reply to you, not elsewhere that you might have missed - stated that a just system would put bullets in these people's heads yesterday. All I'm saying is we need to understand what made them like this in order to keep more of them from existing.

                  • aaro [they/them, she/her]
                    ·
                    edit-2
                    1 year ago

                    Friend. Pal. Buddy. You're making shit up about what I said. I'm not excusing genocide and to accuse me of such is either deliberate bad faith or a straight-out lie. I have genocide victims in my family and I don't want to let you win by knowing that you're pissing me off, but you're pissing me off.

                    I'll read your hour long essay when you demonstrate to me that you have read the thirty seconds of conversation that we're literally having with each other. Until then, I'm reading the other essay I was linked by a person who is far more effective at communicating and coherent than you are.

                • Llituro [he/him, they/them]
                  ·
                  1 year ago

                  the point is that you can recognize both the bad conditions and traumas that would make a person want to accept brainwashing while also understanding their own conscious acquiescence to the material benefits of that situation, and often an integration of the accompanying propaganda. it's not a carrot and a stick, it's popcorn and a movie, but i don't think we have to care per se about which factor is potentially more dominant in making a person a genocide supporter: they're helping do global murder.

                  • EngineerGaming [none/use name]
                    ·
                    1 year ago

                    This comment doesn't actually disagree with the person at all, though. You're right, and they're right. We should be distrustful of veterans, but not because we're mystically superior beings who are just built different. We should be distrustful of them because they have a provably dangerous mindset, given all the murder.

                    So why does the distinction matter? Well, it wouldn't, if people wouldn't also keep bringing morality in the conversation. Once we start talking about some sort of abstract moral judge of character, the distinction becomes very important, because of ethical implications I'm too burnt out right now to explain.

          • autismdragon [he/him, they/them]
            ·
            1 year ago

            I would like to see you actually answer this question because its pretty key to dispelling the notion that you DONT think you were somehow born with "dont participate in genocide" genes.

            This is especially important because military recruits are children. Groomed for killing instead of sex.

            • Huldra [they/them, it/its]
              ·
              1 year ago

              I disagree, I think the whole exchange is sob story bullshit that would be laughed out of the thread if it was applied to any other comparable state.

              This is the kind of dilemma libs fret over when they read about the Nazis and "Oooh geeee I dunno would I be participating in the kristallnacht if I was in Germany? Ooooh I just dont have any agency oooh."

              • autismdragon [he/him, they/them]
                ·
                1 year ago

                Well I don't fall into that strawman so you have to actually engage with my point. I'm an absolutist about this and don't differentiate between nations that did evil.

                OP's point was if you went through the exact same life experiences you'd make the exact same choices. If your reason for believing this isn't true ISNT "I have the dont participate in genocide gene", then what is it? Because "im just born different, my morality is in my bones" is the only explanation for that I can see.

                Its not a fucking sob story because I dont feel sorry for them. I think accountability is necessary when harm is done.

                    • Huldra [they/them, it/its]
                      ·
                      1 year ago

                      I think this line of argument is tedious horseshit meant to ultimately wedge in apologism for veterans no matter the assurance that "oh no I definitely still think the bad ones should get punished", and that this would not be fucking accepted for any other comparable state, yet the American instincts of this site seem to demand endless horrible dogshit debates like this be had no matter what when American veterans are maligned, when the same people would rather hurl than argue like this for something like the IDF.

                      I dont engage with it because of that.

                      • autismdragon [he/him, they/them]
                        ·
                        1 year ago

                        I already said that I dont have that double standard but you're still strawmanning me with it lol. I would absolutely argue this for the IDF lol.

                        • Huldra [they/them, it/its]
                          ·
                          1 year ago

                          Well sure its real fucking easy to say that when confronted with an accusation, but I dont think you would actually, I just do not believe that because I see threads about other militaries and 99 times out of 100 stuff like this isnt said.

                          And I am speaking in general, this thread has over a hundred replies, and there have been like a dozen threads just like this this year. Sorry that you specifically feel strawmanned by me speaking of the general tendencies of this site and not taking your uniqueness into account.

                          • autismdragon [he/him, they/them]
                            ·
                            1 year ago

                            Now you're assuming shit about me lol. I didn't participate in those threads. Sometimes I do fall into screaming the usual bloodthirsty slogans for catharsis reasons but my ethos under all that remains the same. I think retributive justice is morally wrong and useless. I think leftist bloodthirst has gone off the rails. And i'm starting to get more and more angry about it and its past my bedtime so I'm going to log off.

      • EngineerGaming [none/use name]
        ·
        edit-2
        1 year ago

        If you had the same brain, uprising, memories, environment, friends, neighbors, parents, and exact same sequence of events in your life, you would make the same decision.

        This is not apologia for the imperialism or murder. It just means any one of us could have been the murderer if we were born in the wrong place. This also doesn't mean that life is "deterministic", just that our decisions and behavior is formulated entirely by our memories and experiences.

    • SuperNovaCouchGuy2 [any]
      ·
      edit-2
      1 year ago

      Lmfao this is such a good essay, starts off like one of those late 20th century communist tracts and am currently at the middle where the internet language appears, 10/10 never expected to see the words "crab bucket" or "cope" in a communist essay.

      Triumphant, handsome, charismatic, “alpha” men

      Holy shit there's even a reference to Chad.

      These days Orwell’s reputation among socialists is in well-deserved shambles. Invocations of the specter of his memory as some kind of aspirational revolutionary ideal — as a staunch opponent of “totalitarianism” — are increasingly buried under citations proving he was in fact a colonial cop, a rapist, a snitch, a racist, a proud Englishman, and so on

      Based author

    • EngineerGaming [none/use name]
      ·
      edit-2
      1 year ago

      This assumes that everyone who is exposed to propaganda is aware it is propaganda, which seems very optimistic of the political awareness of your average American.

      I don't even have to read the essay, suggesting that everyone who does bad things in service of false claims is doing so for their own benefit and also does not believe those false claims is simply absurd. People are just stupid sometimes. Doesn't justify murder, but the majority of people are not playing some sort of gigabrain 5d chess.

    • aaro [they/them, she/her]
      ·
      1 year ago

      It's not an excuse as in we're letting them off the hook, its an explanation. They will need severe reworking, they're not excused of shit. Many of them can never be fixed and the only option is the pit. But we should be grieving that things ever got to this point and recognizing that they, despite needing the pit, were born loving and caring human beings just as we were, and that the evil forces that didn't quite catch us got to them and did too much damage to ever undo.

      • Huldra [they/them, it/its]
        ·
        1 year ago

        Its a bad explanation, the essay provides a superior one that accounts for the agency and participation of the masses in propaganda.