if you don't put it into practice you can theorize all you want and it amounts to nothing and you do intelectually walk yourself into a doomer position, what can I say. of course its not simple but if you don't attempt to bring about the more militant material conditions through participating in active struggle and injecting yourself into these situations and doing coordinations you wont even know the tiniest extent of the complexities involved on a practical level. not disparaging the work you are citing, its probably an interesting read but sometimes you learn a lot more about the books you read through actually talking and organizing with workers engaged in active struggle, just a thought.