• PaulWall [he/him]
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    4 years ago

    I’m not disagreeing that when you frame it that broadly the system didn’t change, that’s why we need communism. Specifically because the aspect you are talking about didn’t change. but various other important aspects did change from feudalism to capitalism and that’s why they are different modes of production. just like how slavery is a different mode of production from both feudalism and capitalism. these changes are notable and much scholarship has been written about them, like the one i linked you.

    also on an unrelated note, i genuinely apologize for insulting you. it was wrong and completely unrelated to the ideas we were discussing. and as you continue to put effort into this conversation i feel more and more bad about the way in which i acted when it began. i respect your insistence on your point of view and your will to argue for it.

    • RandomWords [he/him]
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      edit-2
      4 years ago

      capitalism and slavery didn't really have 'different' modes of production, just different ways by which they decided the working class.

      people making 7 dollars an hour, many still people of color and illegal immigrants in the usa, working two jobs to maintain a living are on par with slaves.

      the system didn't change much it just made it more pc. anything that pretends it's not the same is liberal revisionism.

      • PaulWall [he/him]
        arrow-down
        1
        ·
        4 years ago

        have you actually read marx? not trying to be an ass but this is like marxism 101. there exists different modes of production sorry to break it to you. i honestly feel like you’re just trolling me at this point or you just literally don’t know.

        (hint those different ways they decide the working class literally are the different modes of production)

          • PaulWall [he/him]
            arrow-down
            1
            ·
            4 years ago

            you’re literally willfully ignoring substantial differences between slavery feudalism and capitalism just so you can paint all of them as capitalism. if you wanted to say they all were the same you could say they all were hierarchal, but no you say they are all just capitalism. your mind has been poisoned by capitalist ideology so throughly that you can’t even recognize a mode of production distinct from it. from within the cave of the the capitalist ideology, everything outside just looks like capitalism too. it’s meant to make you feel like there’s no other alternative and that capitalism is the natural progression of human economics rather than the specific ideology of a ruling class that siezed state power in the 17th century