Some common takes are not related to ML/Anarchist split, but are unpopular with anarchists (Vaush hate, Breadtube hate, not voting, anti-electoralism, anti-harm-reductionism, shitting on AOC, etc.)
I lean towards anarchism myself, and most of the anarchist stuff I've read has been pretty anti-electoralism and anti-social democracy, so I don't get why reddit anarchists have gotten so liberal.
It’s a long term op. Started when the CIA saw how useful anarchists could be when some went to rojava (which was based) but the CIA could see how they could drag the ideological space over a bit until color revolution didn’t seem that different to your average anarchist. It’s a fucking op.
In his 1000 subscriber Q&A he answers this question, here's what he says in that video:
"It's not that I'm such a big fan of the SPD in the 20s and 30s, they weren't really the good guys either in a lot of cases, It's just that I'm a fan of history and like the idea of people coming together to fight for democracy against the forces that try to destroy it."
i dunno if he's said anything more recently, I just remembered this but I haven't been subscribed to him in a while.
I think that she was a bit more left than now, that she did want to express multi faceted views, was much closer (timeline and relational) to the university and academic debates and thus tried to present a bit of leftism with a fun take. That said, she wasn't openly advocating for any explicit revolutionary stream.
Now Contra got money from the videos, which changed her relation to society, she has a lot of input from viewers all over the spectrum, which also skews her views. It might be that she hides her power level, but I doubt it.
Well that's a shame. I remember when Breadtube started, the goal behind it was to push back on all the right-wing propaganda on youtube and try to radicalize people. It seems like instead of radicalizing people it's just de-radicalized people who were already on the left.
It's not deradicalised people who were already on the left. It's just that people making these vids are just radlibs, and they don't know enough about anything. Almost none of them belong to any kind of larger structure, to an organisation or something, or have participated in serious organising and unionising etc. A leftist who has never tried any of that stuff, has never come in contact with serious people who are attempting that, who has never been part of collective struggle etc and thinks they are qualified to talk about stuff after just reading the wiki page about Rojava or even worse, watching vids by other libs who stan democrat slay kweens, is not a leftist.
They're all either utopians, laser-focused on idpol, secretly reactionary or just complete ultras. And that is predictable. It is also predictable that if they continue being as individualistic as they are, if they continue being absent from any serious organising, and if they continue having their audience enforce their echo chamber, chances are they will all end up reactionary.
Anarchists are the canonical anti-electoralists so the whole trend of online "anarchists" telling people to vote for Biden is extremely weird. A real anarchist would call Lenin a lib for justifying bourgeois electoral participation under any pretext at all.
(disclaimer: not an anarchist, but I have known of anarchism since a while before 2016)
tbh it was inevitable the second Koch got back from germany and decided to go cryptofash with the trojan horse of liberty
didn't even know who vaush was til I got on here and I was pretty active on the sub before it got banned
conversely, I've got an anarchist friend who joined the dsa on the opposite end of things because they're the most active leftists in their area besides some vanguardist MLs with a particularly shitty idea of what that means
I had an automod rule that deleted any post or comment with his name in it lmao
genius
full LARP
Door-to-door canvassing to spread disinfo to suppress the primary vote seems more like they got compromised by bad actors than anything else. Tbh the biggest larpers I've met IRL are bougie kids that are into the soviet aesthetic and have no discernable politics.
Did go to a Castro-themed columbus day party thrown by some ansyns once, and that was pretty sweet. Thought it was a larp til I learned the hosts were red card carriers
I lean towards anarchism myself, and most of the anarchist stuff I've read has been pretty anti-electoralism and anti-social democracy, so I don't get why reddit anarchists have gotten so liberal.
It’s a long term op. Started when the CIA saw how useful anarchists could be when some went to rojava (which was based) but the CIA could see how they could drag the ideological space over a bit until color revolution didn’t seem that different to your average anarchist. It’s a fucking op.
deleted by creator
deleted by creator
deleted by creator
deleted by creator
deleted by creator
deleted by creator
He said he’s not a communist, but have never said anything anti-USSR or more broadly anti-communist.
Guy seems to focus on Germany issues and debunking crap histories of WWII, he’s doesn’t seem interested in much beyond that.
deleted by creator
In his 1000 subscriber Q&A he answers this question, here's what he says in that video:
i dunno if he's said anything more recently, I just remembered this but I haven't been subscribed to him in a while.
deleted by creator
deleted by creator
Three Arrows is good, lots of debunking Holocaust denial / Wehrmacht apologia from a modern German perspective.
his video on bolsonaro/the brazilian dictatorship is pretty good
BadEmpanada is not quite breadtube but he does good vids and he posts here too (or at least he used to post in the old sub, idk if he migrated).
deleted by creator
something something master's tools something master's house
matrix room replacement for the discord when
deleted by creator
I think that she was a bit more left than now, that she did want to express multi faceted views, was much closer (timeline and relational) to the university and academic debates and thus tried to present a bit of leftism with a fun take. That said, she wasn't openly advocating for any explicit revolutionary stream.
Now Contra got money from the videos, which changed her relation to society, she has a lot of input from viewers all over the spectrum, which also skews her views. It might be that she hides her power level, but I doubt it.
Well that's a shame. I remember when Breadtube started, the goal behind it was to push back on all the right-wing propaganda on youtube and try to radicalize people. It seems like instead of radicalizing people it's just de-radicalized people who were already on the left.
Breadtube started good for like 6 months then got co-opted by libs.
deleted by creator
It's not deradicalised people who were already on the left. It's just that people making these vids are just radlibs, and they don't know enough about anything. Almost none of them belong to any kind of larger structure, to an organisation or something, or have participated in serious organising and unionising etc. A leftist who has never tried any of that stuff, has never come in contact with serious people who are attempting that, who has never been part of collective struggle etc and thinks they are qualified to talk about stuff after just reading the wiki page about Rojava or even worse, watching vids by other libs who stan democrat slay kweens, is not a leftist.
They're all either utopians, laser-focused on idpol, secretly reactionary or just complete ultras. And that is predictable. It is also predictable that if they continue being as individualistic as they are, if they continue being absent from any serious organising, and if they continue having their audience enforce their echo chamber, chances are they will all end up reactionary.
Anarchists are the canonical anti-electoralists so the whole trend of online "anarchists" telling people to vote for Biden is extremely weird. A real anarchist would call Lenin a lib for justifying bourgeois electoral participation under any pretext at all.
(disclaimer: not an anarchist, but I have known of anarchism since a while before 2016)
deleted by creator
yeah that seems more like shit that's unpopular with succdems than anything else
deleted by creator
TFW Russian nationalists use Stalin imagery :stalin-shining:
deleted by creator
tbh it was inevitable the second Koch got back from germany and decided to go cryptofash with the trojan horse of liberty
didn't even know who vaush was til I got on here and I was pretty active on the sub before it got banned
conversely, I've got an anarchist friend who joined the dsa on the opposite end of things because they're the most active leftists in their area besides some vanguardist MLs with a particularly shitty idea of what that means
deleted by creator
genius
Door-to-door canvassing to spread disinfo to suppress the primary vote seems more like they got compromised by bad actors than anything else. Tbh the biggest larpers I've met IRL are bougie kids that are into the soviet aesthetic and have no discernable politics.
Did go to a Castro-themed columbus day party thrown by some ansyns once, and that was pretty sweet. Thought it was a larp til I learned the hosts were red card carriers
deleted by creator
Suddenly it makes sense how Vaush came out of nowhere.
We need an automod here.
deleted by creator
deleted by creator