So, I actually saw the first 6 minutes of TDKR in Imax as a "preview" about 4 or 5 months before the movie came out and the audio was fine then. A big part of Bane's issue was that they changed the mix after a bunch of stupid assholes watched a fucking cam rip of the Imax preview and couldn't understand any of it. They fucked it up when they changed it. But you're right, his audio mix is dumb as fuck as a rule.
But NOT! ever as dumb as his editing, holy fucking christ, he needs to shoot his editor.
I also saw the preview- I disagree, I thought that sound edit was incomprehensible. The film was much more bearable, but not perfect.
Disagree with the editor as well- on top of the fact the editor is probably railroaded by Nolan himself, I actually think his films editing is terrific
The sound is also probably theater dependent. Even a lot of "real" IMAX theaters are in disarray these days, with shit not being replaced or tuned correctly.
His editor I'm willing to give a pass, as its probably more due to Nolan's trash coverage than the editing itself.
So, I actually saw the first 6 minutes of TDKR in Imax as a "preview" about 4 or 5 months before the movie came out and the audio was fine then. A big part of Bane's issue was that they changed the mix after a bunch of stupid assholes watched a fucking cam rip of the Imax preview and couldn't understand any of it. They fucked it up when they changed it. But you're right, his audio mix is dumb as fuck as a rule.
But NOT! ever as dumb as his editing, holy fucking christ, he needs to shoot his editor.
I also saw the preview- I disagree, I thought that sound edit was incomprehensible. The film was much more bearable, but not perfect.
Disagree with the editor as well- on top of the fact the editor is probably railroaded by Nolan himself, I actually think his films editing is terrific
The sound is also probably theater dependent. Even a lot of "real" IMAX theaters are in disarray these days, with shit not being replaced or tuned correctly.
His editor I'm willing to give a pass, as its probably more due to Nolan's trash coverage than the editing itself.