Looks like Socialist Alternative is going to try to make DSA form a workers party by having some of it's members join DSA.
Current DSA by-laws allow for chapters to expel members for being in Democratic Centralist organizations but its not automatic. It also seems like SAlt isn't telling their members to join en-masse, just a few to push for a new workers party at meetings.
My DSA chapter isn't happy about this but it seems like most apprehension seems to be from their experience with individual SAlt members, first and the rudeness of the tactic, second. But there seems to be little consideration of their goals.
Becuase the caucuses would be invested in the power of their parent organization while an external organization would only be tangentially so.
I think the scenario we're trying to avoid is members from another org showing up, voting for the interest of their org, then going back to work for their org.
That's fair, but would you prefer all SAlt members joining DSA and becoming a caucus themselves? They'd be a significant amount od DSA memebrs immediatly if they did that. I'm guessing around 5%
I don't think SAlt should dissolve themselves nationally just to join the DSA nor do I think they ever would. Its seems they just want to more closely cooperate with local dsa chapters.
Trots have a history of switching between being a party and a tendency inside another, broader left party. It's not impossible at all. If they start believing that DSA is the new workers party inside the US, then they'll do it, just like they've followed that strategy in every country around the globe.