Thing is, there are plenty of books that are called "comics" for various reasons, such as Maus, compilations of weekly publications of a non-strip serial (e.g. tankobons)*, and some other cases.
*compare to how many classic novels, e.g. work by Charles Dickens, were initially published chapter-by-chapter but are now read as compilations. Many manga as well as western comics also get published this way (e.g. I have an old Daredevil book that was originally published on a monthly basis but reads just fine consecutively as a unified book)
Right, a lot of "graphic novels" are serialized. But there's a difference between Watchmen running for 12 issues to tell its entire story and some Superman series running for 12+ years. No one would call One Piece a graphic novel; it takes up an entire bookcase.
They might call a tankobon or a larger volume of One Piece a graphic novel if it was formatted in an episodic way (e.g. the "Romance Dawn" arc, the first 7 chapters, in one book), because at that point it would be very much like serialized graphic novels in the west, or at least the ones that I'm familiar with. Even with the ones that would take a few books, it's not like we don't have things like "John Flodstritum and the Amulet of Nevar, Pt 3" being published as "graphic novels.
Thing is, there are plenty of books that are called "comics" for various reasons, such as Maus, compilations of weekly publications of a non-strip serial (e.g. tankobons)*, and some other cases.
*compare to how many classic novels, e.g. work by Charles Dickens, were initially published chapter-by-chapter but are now read as compilations. Many manga as well as western comics also get published this way (e.g. I have an old Daredevil book that was originally published on a monthly basis but reads just fine consecutively as a unified book)
Right, a lot of "graphic novels" are serialized. But there's a difference between Watchmen running for 12 issues to tell its entire story and some Superman series running for 12+ years. No one would call One Piece a graphic novel; it takes up an entire bookcase.
They might call a tankobon or a larger volume of One Piece a graphic novel if it was formatted in an episodic way (e.g. the "Romance Dawn" arc, the first 7 chapters, in one book), because at that point it would be very much like serialized graphic novels in the west, or at least the ones that I'm familiar with. Even with the ones that would take a few books, it's not like we don't have things like "John Flodstritum and the Amulet of Nevar, Pt 3" being published as "graphic novels.