Ngl I prefer the Johnny Depp version because Gene Wilder seems too well adjusted. Depp's Willy is a freak a recluse and a slave owner, and he tries to murder 4 children and acts like it wasn't his fault. And obviously no one is going to seriously challenge the man who just had his slaves come out and sing a song about how terrible your child was after drowning said child. Wonka is clearly a madman in this movie and its hilarious