An online post by the Communist Party Youth League and state broadcaster CCTV used the fate of Kong Yiji to scold the young and jobless as arrogant and lazy. Kong failed “because he couldn’t let go of the airs of a scholar and was unwilling to change his situation through labor,” the post lectured. Xi—who has said he opposes the “idleness-breeding trap of welfarism”—has told his nation’s struggling youth to learn to “eat bitterness.”
more context matters, is it because he's a dummy boomer or is it because there's tons of work to do and some random fascist empire is outside banging on your windows, doors, and walls?
It can definitely be both! He can have views on “welfarism” that sound reactionary to Americans while his words are straight up honest about the threat and necessity of hard work. You can see the press slavering at the “lie flat movement” or any hint that Chinese youth will abandon the party’s goals of socialism and growth apart from the western model
I mean the lie flat movement is a natural response to how turbo-charged the competition in China's education and work systems have become in the last generation. It's a genuine problem in Chinese society right now and to refuse to participate in that aspect is a good thing - but what I hope those in the lie flat movement understand is that liberalism does not offer them an escape from that aspect of Chinese society, just look at South Korea and Japan. The only way for China's work culture to improve is for it to be reformed within the socialist model while the people still have control over their society, rather than having yielded control of it over to market forces.
Yeah I don’t disagree, but these are taken as signs of the opposite, that more markets and more treats from the west surely solve the broader crisis of capitalism China (and all nations) must grapple with, rather than exacerbating it
the main issue here is that just as many if not more chinese people don't actually want to fix the problem of competition, they LIKE the competition, the competition is GOOD, the competition is NOT the problem, because if there was no competition, they wouldn't be able to win
the REAL problem is that they're not winning
it's one step up from the american 'temporarily embarrassed millionaires'; chinese strivers are capable of recognizing wishful thinking for what it is, but the sheer need for and capability to execute on dumb striver shit to fulfill dumb striver motives just to be able to lord it over their peer group is quite literally ruining the country rn. the entire educational system (and culture at large tbh) is caught in a negative feedback loop of artificially inflated standards and the government has no fucking idea how to solve it
an abundance of needlessly well made powerpoint presentations is a portent for the end of nations
Worth mentioning that "welfarism" is not the same thing as "welfare," just like "electoralism" is not the same thing as "participating in elections," etc. At least that is the case in English -- and I am sure they would have translated it as "welfare" if they could have because that sounds worse. Idk what the nuanced meaning of the Chinese term translated as "welfarism" is though.
mfw I am chinawatching
whoa if true
Eat bitterness has a different context in Chinese, but Xi is definitely against the idea of welfare programs compared to other social spending
I see, thank you for explaining the meaning behind that.
more context matters, is it because he's a dummy boomer or is it because there's tons of work to do and some random fascist empire is outside banging on your windows, doors, and walls?
It can definitely be both! He can have views on “welfarism” that sound reactionary to Americans while his words are straight up honest about the threat and necessity of hard work. You can see the press slavering at the “lie flat movement” or any hint that Chinese youth will abandon the party’s goals of socialism and growth apart from the western model
I mean the lie flat movement is a natural response to how turbo-charged the competition in China's education and work systems have become in the last generation. It's a genuine problem in Chinese society right now and to refuse to participate in that aspect is a good thing - but what I hope those in the lie flat movement understand is that liberalism does not offer them an escape from that aspect of Chinese society, just look at South Korea and Japan. The only way for China's work culture to improve is for it to be reformed within the socialist model while the people still have control over their society, rather than having yielded control of it over to market forces.
Yeah I don’t disagree, but these are taken as signs of the opposite, that more markets and more treats from the west surely solve the broader crisis of capitalism China (and all nations) must grapple with, rather than exacerbating it
the main issue here is that just as many if not more chinese people don't actually want to fix the problem of competition, they LIKE the competition, the competition is GOOD, the competition is NOT the problem, because if there was no competition, they wouldn't be able to win
the REAL problem is that they're not winning
it's one step up from the american 'temporarily embarrassed millionaires'; chinese strivers are capable of recognizing wishful thinking for what it is, but the sheer need for and capability to execute on dumb striver shit to fulfill dumb striver motives just to be able to lord it over their peer group is quite literally ruining the country rn. the entire educational system (and culture at large tbh) is caught in a negative feedback loop of artificially inflated standards and the government has no fucking idea how to solve it
an abundance of needlessly well made powerpoint presentations is a portent for the end of nations
Worth mentioning that "welfarism" is not the same thing as "welfare," just like "electoralism" is not the same thing as "participating in elections," etc. At least that is the case in English -- and I am sure they would have translated it as "welfare" if they could have because that sounds worse. Idk what the nuanced meaning of the Chinese term translated as "welfarism" is though.