It probably won't go beyond just "asking questions" and "what if" discussions, but even so. From 2015 to 2023, just talking about class in any way was considered 'racist and sexist' in lib circles. I guess they want to shift their rhetoric closer to the left for the 2024 elections, but not proposing any policies that this rhetoric would logically imply. Look, you stupid leftists, we are talking the same way that Bernie did in 2016/2020, you should support Joe 2024!
I once saw an interview with David Brooks where I didn’t know who he was, and I couldn’t believe how stupid he was. Then I saw that it was David Brooks, and I was like, oh yeah, of course. He was talking with fucking Aaron Sorkin and would not shut the fuck up about how he and his children went to the most elite schools. He also asked Sorkin if he drank when he wrote and Sorkin looked at him like, is this a trick question? But Brooks legitimately did not know that a bag of cocaine had essentially written The West Wing.
I read the article and thought it was basically a liberal struggling to do class analysis without Marxism. The educated elites in this country are the labor aristocracy, who overwhelmingly support the democrats, while the petite bourgeoisie overwhelmingly supports Trump. But because liberals don’t know that class is determined by your relationship to the means of production, they think that income determines class (labor aristocrats can make more money than the petite bourgeoisie), and that Trump supporters are workers. (Some are—highly educated tech bros or aging white male union workers can indeed support Trump. Small business owners can also support Biden.) The result here is just a worthless mess, with Brooks humblebragging about an elite pedigree that only proves that an ivy league education is no guarantee of even minimal intelligence.
I remember Chapo doing a reading series on some profile of Brooks. In it, he had this big revelation (at like age 55), that other people are also individuals like him and also have their lives and thoughts. Something basic like that. You can see why it was easy for him to support the Iraq war, because he had the most basic humanist realization at 55, whereas most people have it at like 12.