They’re bad folks, everybody knows it, everybody says it. But they’re simultaneously better and worse than you think, because apparently nobody actually knows how these products actually work. (I’m mostly going to be discussing google home, because that’s what I’m familiar with; I assume echos use similar technology, but I can’t speak for them).
So to get started, no, your smart speaker isn’t always listening. At a hardware level, there’s two boards and a tiny bit of cache. Your speaker is constantly listening for the trigger words, and processing about 2 seconds of audio stored on the cache at a time. However, this is all done at a local level on the first board. Only once it recognizes the trigger words does it establish a connection to the cloud, and use that to process your request. Once your request is complete, it goes back into standby mode. You can look at the packets coming out of the device, and see that it only connects to the internet when it needs to. The onboard cache is small, and constantly being overwritten, so there’s literally no way for it to constantly be monitoring you, by design.
However, what IS nefarious is the amount of permissions you have to give google in regards to the data it does capture. Of course, they use the captured audio for expected things like training their voice recognition AI, but you also give them permission to store all that data indefinitely, with metadata tracing it back to you, AND it’s not off limits to engineers.
That’s right, there’s the possibility, however small, that real people will be listening whenever you ask google to play your erotic jazz playlist. Once that audio is on the cloud, you basically don’t own it anymore, and google can do whatever they want with it.
So should you be worried? If you want to be, I guess. I resigned to the fact that I lost all my digital privacy before I was even born, and will happily tell google to turn off my lights while laying in bed like a fat sack of shit, but it comes down to what you’re comfortable with. Either way, I just want people to actually understand what they are and how they work, because there is a lot to criticize, so it pays to be criticizing the right things.
Smart TVs screenshot what you're watching at a regular interval and sell your viewing habit data, or access to it, to marketers. This happends regardless of which video input you're using.
They'll also display ads whenever they want because fuck you.
Some smart TVs will also try to connect to open Wi-Fi networks to send this data home , regardless of whether you've set up networking. Once they start putting sim cards in these you'll need to start opening them up and wiring a resistor in place of the antannae or something. Or stick to using dumb TVs.
Also if you're going to build a smart home, use FOSS software like Home Assistant and stick to hardware that either doesn't need an internet connection to operate or can be flashed with an alternative firmware to work locally.
In capitalist America, TV watches you
Time to start writing diaries in the closet.
Does anyone even make those anymore? Though my sample size is pretty much only from the walmart here, but I haven't seen a normal ass TV for close to years.
I suppose you could use a large computer monitor and a TV tuner if you really can't find one.
I got a 55” 4k dumb tv from walmart last year. So maybe they do still.
Why would a TV need a SIM card?
What does God need with a starship?
So, 10 year old 1080p TVs?
deleted by creator