Dwarves who have big noses and go mad for treasure and gold?
Did Tolkien ever explicately state they were an allegory for Jews? cuz if not I’ve never thought that made much sense.
Yes Dwarves love gold and jewels, but they also mine those gold and jewels themselves with pickaxes and swole dwarf arms, and they’re also known for being stubborn and aggressive and love drinking and fighting. Jews are usually stereotyped as physically weak and so have to rely on schemes and trickery to thrive. I don’t see many antisemetic 4chan memes of Jews drinking tankards of ale after a long day of smelting battle axes, or fantasy books where Dwarves use loan sharking scheme to destabilize a Goblin kingdom.
Did Tolkien ever explicately state they were an allegory for Jews?
He absolutely did, yes. The dwarvish language of Khuzdul is even based on Hebrew. It wasn't intended to be a denigrating comparison, though. The dwarves were the heroes in The Hobbit.
Also, anti-Semitic stereotypes in the early 20th century are different than today. There was indeed stereotypes of them being good at wrestling and fighting, being unhygienic and unshaven & short.
It’s a feudal society, it wouldn’t make much sense for dwarves to have complex financial schemes. They do get mentioned as hoarders and stealers though, and their greed attracts a dragon which the humans have to fight off for them.
There was indeed stereotypes of them being good at wrestling and fighting, being unhygienic and unshaven & short.
Really? That's pretty stark contrast to the stereotypes of Jews I encounter today, usually they're portrayed as kinda nerdy, orderly and necrotic, "smelly bearded wrestler" isn't really what pops into my head when I think of Jews.
Edit: Also didn't the idea of Jews being bankers come from the fact there were one of the few people who were doing banking in the feudal era? I've never known Jews to be associated with mining or metallurgy so that element of the dwarves is weird.
I don't know why you guys are acting like Tolkien invented dwarves. He cribbed them from Norse and German mythology basically wholesale. They were already an established thing, short, mythologically good at smithing, often insular and hostile.
Did Tolkien ever explicately state they were an allegory for Jews? cuz if not I’ve never thought that made much sense.
Yes Dwarves love gold and jewels, but they also mine those gold and jewels themselves with pickaxes and swole dwarf arms, and they’re also known for being stubborn and aggressive and love drinking and fighting. Jews are usually stereotyped as physically weak and so have to rely on schemes and trickery to thrive. I don’t see many antisemetic 4chan memes of Jews drinking tankards of ale after a long day of smelting battle axes, or fantasy books where Dwarves use loan sharking scheme to destabilize a Goblin kingdom.
He absolutely did, yes. The dwarvish language of Khuzdul is even based on Hebrew. It wasn't intended to be a denigrating comparison, though. The dwarves were the heroes in The Hobbit.
I always saw the dwarves as the proletarians of middle earth. Hobbits were kinda peasants and elves were the inteligista.
Allegories and metaphors aren’t usually 1:1
Also, anti-Semitic stereotypes in the early 20th century are different than today. There was indeed stereotypes of them being good at wrestling and fighting, being unhygienic and unshaven & short.
It’s a feudal society, it wouldn’t make much sense for dwarves to have complex financial schemes. They do get mentioned as hoarders and stealers though, and their greed attracts a dragon which the humans have to fight off for them.
Really? That's pretty stark contrast to the stereotypes of Jews I encounter today, usually they're portrayed as kinda nerdy, orderly and necrotic, "smelly bearded wrestler" isn't really what pops into my head when I think of Jews.
Edit: Also didn't the idea of Jews being bankers come from the fact there were one of the few people who were doing banking in the feudal era? I've never known Jews to be associated with mining or metallurgy so that element of the dwarves is weird.
Yeah, something about usury laws I think.
I don't know why you guys are acting like Tolkien invented dwarves. He cribbed them from Norse and German mythology basically wholesale. They were already an established thing, short, mythologically good at smithing, often insular and hostile.