America being largest producer of ‘culture’ and having such a large geopolitical influence means that lots of countries compares itself to it. Because of its cultural hegemony most people know what’s broadly going on in the US, this means that any criticism of your country is dismissed or lessened by ‘at least we’re not America lol’.
I live in Australia, if you discuss adding dental or mental health to Medicare for example, people will inevitably say ‘at least we aren’t America’.
In the Queensland election news coverage on the ABC tonight, the analyst mentioned how great it is that the election results are accepted and it’s it’s just another day in democracy, as opposed to the US where everyone is prepared for the election to be contested and there’s voter suppression. While this IS true, and I do appreciate living in a semi-social liberal democracy that functions closer to intended, this detracts from the issues we have, discourages improvement and makes people feel complacent and smug.
Thoughts?
EDIT: the police is a good example too, if you critique the police you’ll often get a response like:
‘come on mate, our police aren’t that bad, not like in America where they shoot every black person they see, and sometimes even non black people(!) just for the heck of it, and they get of scott free, shits fucked there mate we got it pretty good aye. AUSSIE AUSSIE AUSSIE.’
Completely agree. There's an odd inferiority/superiority complex amongst Anglo nations to compare themselves to the US in every aspect from racism to healthcare to foreign policy and imperialism. In the UK, they will happily insist they're "not racist" like they are in the US, whilst happily throwing bananas on the football pitch when a black player turns up.
The same applies to healthcare where any critique or desire for improvement is deflected back to the guys who do it worse, i.e.; the US, whilst in the same breath selling off the NHS piecemeal to foreign investors. The UK is not a warmongering imperialist nation, they'll claim, whilst happily following the US in every foreign imperial boondoggle and pretend they were dragging their feet and forced into it. Never mind the ways imperialism can be performed without being at gunpoint.
The most valid claims against the US have to do with its obsession with the state, the nationalism, the worship of its political figures and institutions which simply don't figure in Anglo discourse... Unless you mention the Royals, in which case it's basically sacrilege, treason, sedition and worthy of exile and death penalty.
But all in all, the worst part of the critique comes in the form of what basically amounts to smug rubbing in of the better material conditions those nations are in at the expense of financially poor working-class Americans who have no desire to be in those conditions and have no way to escape or resolve them as the country is, by design, not a democracy, and has a vested owner class that controls every aspect of their social politics and economics. Ultimately, it abandons any pretense of international solidarity and makes them pat themselves on the back that they'll never be as bad as the US, and that therefore nothing needs to change, and that Americans are all ignorant and stupid bible-thumpers who want things to be this way (unlike the enlightened commonwealthers they are).
Canada's the worst for the not-racist thing.
Almost everything in Canada gets compared to the States and we feel better about ourselves
Healthcare
Education
Sure we are better there, but it's not good enough
Racism? That we feel better, but I don't think we actually are
had a fun conversation with a canadain reactionary on facebook recently where they were whining about the american polarized discourse infecting canada (OP was about the sports wildcat strikes in support of BLM, their comment was about canadian hockey fans quitting the NHL)
told them to ask the land defenders if black lives matter
they took that as an opportunity to grandstand on how that's exactly what they were talking about, so I just replied w/ skoden
People are so fucking depressing
The amount of colonialist denialism in this country is wild. And the related accepted distain of indigenous peoples.
thank you, came here to talk about canada. my drivers license says louisiana but i live in ontario. i haven't met this many ignorant rich white people since i drove through marin county.
here in hamilton they spent two hours holding a cardboard sign supporting BLM, which is fine, but not one of them hires a black person, not one of them knows the name of First Nations leaders, and to boot almost all of them are islamophobic.
the white ruling class of ontario is as corrupt and backwards as any southern state i've ever lived.
Fuck we have the same opinions about Ontarians. It's actually disturbing how much Ontario is like a mini America, fuck I wanna go back to BC.
I'm sure that Ontario's worse but don't let the province most actively engaged in genocide off the hook like that.
Yeesh that's true. Canada, it's bad folks
i call it up upper-buffalo.
"Not racist just dont like em. Simple as."
"If I'm racist, then why's [Foreign name] me favourite player?"
LOVE NGUBU, LOVE ME MISSUS, LOVE ME COUNTRY, LOVE BORIS. ATE JEREMY CORBYN, ATE NONCES, ATE TRANSGENDAHS, ATE TRAVELLERS, SIMPLE AS.