Likewise! I love that meme. Seriously: I totally dig the idea of grumpy grizzled old man cynic Luke. I'm just not a fan of how they got him there. The idea that Luke would have turned cynical and decided his entire philosophical worldview was wrong because he had a moment of weakness and nearly did the antithesis of everything he ever preached is just flat on its face idiocy. Its like a priest rejecting his faith because he was tempted to break one of the commandments or something. It makes no sense. If anything he would have doubled down and reaffirmed his position to never be tempted again.

If they wanted to make Luke a cynic it had to come from a failure of his idealistic worldview rather then a personal failure to follow it.