Say it without crying

  • KrasMazovThought [comrade/them]
    ·
    4 years ago

    in the long run, stocks always trend towards their actual value

    How do you determine what a stock's "actual" value is, independently of the market? There a thousand artificial and arbitrary actions and injections that deliberately shape stock trends and the market.

    • OneToughNerd [he/him]
      ·
      4 years ago

      Because a "stock" is just a part share ownership in a business. It's value is based on the intrinsic value of that business. There's definitely an art to it as much as a science, and it's a long term trend. Unless you're a moron who believes in the efficient market hypothesis, price and value don't always match up but trend towards each other. Fundamentally, people aren't going to keep paying 30 cents for a quarter or sell a dime for 8 cents forever.

      • KrasMazovThought [comrade/them]
        ·
        4 years ago

        It’s value is based on the intrinsic value of that business.

        Okay, so. How is the intrinsic value of that business determined? Is there a reliable formula? Do you then have any data to show that the market value actually trends towards the intrinsic value?

        • OneToughNerd [he/him]
          ·
          4 years ago

          How is the intrinsic value of that business determined?

          All kinds of ways :). Check our Benjamin Graham's work on this like "Security Analysis". It's based on a combo of expected business profits and the value of all

          Remember a stock is a REAL THING. You are an owner when you own stock, even if you're just a trader. You own a piece of that business and its profits, assets, future profits, etc.

          Do you then have any data to show that the market value actually trends towards the intrinsic value?

          Do you have any data to show that the price of a quarter trends towards 25 cents? Ask Warren Buffett about how he made his money.

          In his case, it was very easy because there were a lot of good deals back then. In particular, Buffet would target companies whose market cap was less than the book value. "Market cap" means "how much would it cost to buy all of the stock". "Book value" is how much all their shit is worth (land, factories, equipment). If the book value is let's say $1/share and the stock

          It's more complicated than that now, but the "data" is the millions of rent seekers who earn a living in the same manner as Buffet.

        • OneToughNerd [he/him]
          ·
          4 years ago

          Tesla will either crash, or there's insider shenanigans going on.

          Prices trend towards intrinsic value in the long run. Prices can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent, as they say.

          • femboi [they/them, she/her]
            ·
            4 years ago

            So there’s no way to make money off of knowing that Tesla is incredibly overvalued because very rich people could just continue to sink money into it, keeping the price high for the foreseeable future?

            • OneToughNerd [he/him]
              ·
              4 years ago

              Yes.

              There's ways to make money, but there's an element of luck involved. It's like betting on a coin that you know has a 51% chance of coming up tails and you have to guess the over/under on tails out of 1000 coin flips