First of all I will refer you to this comrade's comment, who I think is correct about the general situation and it's a great TL;DR.

But since Belarus is in the megathread now, I thought I'd share my personal experiences growing up there, being very political, and sort of changing my mind a little after I learned a more about imperialism let's say.

  1. Belarus is low-key Syria of Europe. Historically, it had been the buffer state between East and West, and suffered greatly for it, especially during the World Wars. 1/4 of the population had been killed during the second one by some estimates. Imagine.

  2. Pompeo visited Belarus in July. No one of that caliber visited Belarus in... ever? Offering oil and gas, the stuff Belarus gets from Russia. It's not even sus, this is just open tug of war between the US and Russia. All that CIA stuff? For sure. I know a few people who work in the USAID in Minsk. They think they are doing a democracy while advancing the World Bank's and the IMF agenda.

  3. I was the "opposition" in my early 20s in Belarus. Campaigning for democratic candidates, getting arrested, all that. Lukashenka is a fuck, no doubt about it. People were murdered and disappeared on his or his cronies' command. He has his hand in all kinds of businesses. Tobacco, fish, who knows what else. Very little goes without his say business-wise. His oldest son runs state owned Belarusian lottery last time I checked. He fucked the constitution to let himself get reelected indefinite amount of terms.

  4. Here's the problem from a comrade's perspective. I wouldn't vote for Lukashenka, but I wouldn't vote for any of the other candidates either even if the elections were transparent as glass. What do they want? They fucking want more privatization. That's what they want. They think democracy is more capitalism, to caricaturize it a little. Because they don't know what kind of hell full neoliberal capitalism is yet! Because state stuff is ran "inefficiently." And yea, it is ran inefficiently. But giving state factories to some fucking dudes with money--that'll be Russia in the 90s all over again. A bunch of well connected people buying up state property for pennies and doing an oligarchy. This will benefit a different group of people, but not the Belarusian people.

  5. That's what this proxy fight between the US and Russia is about in my opinion. Who gets to control of Belarusian assets. Whichever side wins, Belarusians loose, whether they know it it or not. Yea Lukashenka has to go. But there seems to be no one to replace him this time around. It's fucked like this, whatever happens it's a loss.

  6. In other words and to sum up, just as Belarus is in a way stuck in the semi-socialist past, which now I am realizing, healthcare-wise and certain other things-wise is superior to the US for example, especially for the poorest layer of the population--as much as it is stuck in the past it is also stuck in the sense of "class consciousness." A lot of people have come to believe, through American movies and propaganda, that freedom is indeed free commerce. I was one of them for a very long time.

  7. There are communist parties in Belarus, but they are weak, very weak, they are not a big force for many reasons. Younger people think it's just stupid nostalgia. Older people remember standing in lines for food. (Belarus, compared to Russia post 1986 was doing relatively well in that regard actually). So no one takes Marx seriously in there. That stuff is not taught there either anymore.

  8. Make no mistake. There are still some socialized aspects in Belarus, but it is full blown capitalism like anywhere else. Wage labor. 30 types of ice cream that you can buy from a couple of huge supermarket chains owned by a couple of people.

I'll answer your questions, sorry for this turning out rambly.

  • qwerty [he/him]
    hexagon
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    4 years ago

    I think it is possible that he would have won without the rigging and got, say 55% of the votes. But we will never know because there was rigging, as always: ballot staffing, observers not allowed in, they even removed the curtain in polling booths to make it less anonymous because there was a campaign to take a pic of your ballot and send it to a dedicated website so that the ballots can be counted independently. When you arrest two of your main opponents so that they can't participate in the election, that's rigging to and it also nothing new and happened before. Lukashenka likes what he calls "elegant victories," 80% of votes and up, and he's been having elegant victories every four years...

    Older people like Lukashenka better, in part because he always makes pensions his rallying card, and no matter the economic turmoil in the country he tries to keep the pension system afloat. None of my younger friends like him or voted for him. Same with my parents. But I cannot speak for everyone.

    • PhaseFour [he/him]
      ·
      edit-2
      4 years ago

      When you arrest two of your main opponents so that they can’t participate in the election, that’s rigging to and it also nothing new and happened before.

      Tsikhanouskaya and who else? And do you know the grounds on which Tsikhanouskaya was arrested?

      Given the history of imperialist intervention in countries aligned against the US empire, I just assumed he was arrested on legitimate grounds. Like Leopoldo Lopez in Venezuela (predecessor to Guiado), who was arrested for proven ties to the CIA & organizing violence actions where hundreds of pro-Chavismo Venezuelans have been murdered. Although, I'm not informed on opposition groups in Belarus.

      • qwerty [he/him]
        hexagon
        arrow-down
        1
        ·
        edit-2
        4 years ago

        No it's a little different in Belarus unfortunately. People get arrested all the time especially before the elections. I was in courts. Last time around minor leaders would be arrested 10 days or so before the election, get 2 weeks sentences for something like disturbing public peace, so that they cannot lead protests when the election results are announced.

        Tikhanovsky is who was arrested, for something like "violence against the police" (ACAB). Tsikhanouskaya is his wife who ran instead of him (smart move). Another big opponent, Tsepkalo, was being investigated for alleged corruption, but he didn't want to wait for the results of the investigation and fled to Russia.

        edit: many opposition groups in Belarus are in one way or the other sponsored or supported by the West. i was in one of them as i learned later. from their perspective it's a righteous fight for democracy helped by fellow democratic countries. from the state perspective this is foreign interference. what i'm trying to say is that there are justified charges and not justified charges, it is not clean in that way in Belarus. Luklashenka is not Castro in that way. and there have not yet been any CIA-backed violent overthrows or death squads. so the situation is also fairly different

        • PhaseFour [he/him]
          ·
          4 years ago

          I appreciate you taking the time to elaborate. Learning about the Belarus protests & the fact that Belarus has been anti-EU & anti-NATO set off major alarms in my mind. I think I have a better understanding of the situation now.