Has anyone provided an iota of evidence that what is driving this horrific surge of anti-Asian violence is "white supremacist domestic terror"?That would require data showing who is primarily perpetrating the violence and with what motive. Where is that? https://t.co/7p7mUmloDW— Glenn Greenwald (@ggreenwald) March 17, 2021
I know we're in the dunk tank and it's old chapo tradition to interpret everything posted here in the worst faith possible, but maybe Glenn Greenwald, an investigative journalist, wants to say that it's extremely irresponsible to play the alt-right game of screaming the name of the opposing group the second a mass shooting occurs just so we control the narrative for a moment.
FFS the top post was an obviously fake FB post by the guy (luckily deleted now). Yes, he killed asian women. That's a suspicion. But not proof.
The guy went around targeting Asian women specifically. He didn't only kill asian women he targeted them. Going to two separate massage parlors,with some distance between them,to do the shootings. It's not screaming the name of the opposing group to say that this guy has some racist and sexist motives behind these murders.
Is the mere act of only targeting Asian-descent women at massage parlors not evidence of racism? Yeah he didn't write a manifesto (that we know of) before doing these murders, but damn I feel like this is an awfully high level epistemological standards.
I've read (and I am taking with a grain of salt) that he was seen at those places before/has visited as a patron and it's frankly just as likely this is more specific to targeting sex workers/women than a straight up racism thing. Of course, it can also be a combination of these factors, or we can step back and discuss the myriad of factors why asian women were the majority of workers there, etc. I'm not trying to discount the element race plays into this, at all, but it has also been odd seeing people online parading around a single, likely faked, screenshot as proof not only of this asshole's intent, but also as like the "poster child" for how the media's rhetoric is inspiring violence. I think it's reasonably fair to assume that race was a factor, but was this necessarily motivated by covid-19 coverage, as people claim? I don't know, personally
Except i didn't mean to dismiss what you said as baseless at all. The fact that mostly Asians died in the attack is an important factor, but just that won't make a hate crime charge stand. And whatever the guy's motivation was, seems like he's playing on that,
There's obviously a rise of sinophobic violence in this country and I don't doubt for a second that racism and sexism are to blame here. That said, there's equal evidence in what you just said that this guy hated massage parlors.
He doesn't hate the women and workers at the parlor, just the idea of the parlor itself.
I don't think that's a very good line of reasoning. By that logic there's also evidence that the guy merely hates shops that are open late, because both of these places where open late.
That's not exactly what I'm saying. Just that if you can make a connection between him targeting women or Asians, you can make a connection with him targeting massage parlors. It's not like he went and shot up a Chinese food restaurant or something. He went after a specific type of business.
He’s not even saying “reserve judgement on this particular shooting” he’s saying that there’s no proof that the general uptick in anti-Asian violence has anything to do with white supremacy.
There's a point to be made that sinophobia and anti-asian racism is a broader and more mainstream ideology than explicit white supremacism is (with the obvious caveat that it's inherently linked to and derived from the American civic nationalist cult which is itself inextricably tied to white supremacist ideology, even if the way this manifests in a given person may favor one facet over another or even actively seek to hide some facets), but that's not the way to make that point.
with the obvious caveat that it’s inherently linked to and derived from the American civic nationalist cult which is itself inextricably tied to white supremacist ideology, even if the way this manifests in a given person may favor one facet over another or even actively seek to hide some facets
This seems like an over-intellectualizing the fact that the US is pushing war propaganda against China right now.
Yes, it can be connected back to white supremacy. But calling the current Sinophobia & anti-Asian racism "white supremacist" provides cover for Sinophobes who no one would consider white supremacists e.g. Ilhan Omar & AOC.
I agree with what you everything you said, though. Just wanted to include this criticism. It applies to everyone in this thread.
Yes, it can be connected back to white supremacy. But calling the current Sinophobia & anti-Asian racism “white supremacist” provides cover for Sinophobes who no one would consider white supremacists e.g. Ilhan Omar & AOC.
Yeah, that's basically my point, I just felt the need to acknowledge that yes, American nationalism is tied to white supremacist ideology even if someone touting it or an offshoot of it may profess anti-racist sentiment or even be in active conflict with the more overtly racist nationalists.
this forum's obsession with trying to dunk on glenn is just as sad/tiresome as glenn's obsession with trying to dunk on whomever (I honestly don't know or care to learn). who gives a shit, you worms.
I know we're in the dunk tank and it's old chapo tradition to interpret everything posted here in the worst faith possible, but maybe Glenn Greenwald, an investigative journalist, wants to say that it's extremely irresponsible to play the alt-right game of screaming the name of the opposing group the second a mass shooting occurs just so we control the narrative for a moment.
FFS the top post was an obviously fake FB post by the guy (luckily deleted now). Yes, he killed asian women. That's a suspicion. But not proof.
The guy went around targeting Asian women specifically. He didn't only kill asian women he targeted them. Going to two separate massage parlors,with some distance between them,to do the shootings. It's not screaming the name of the opposing group to say that this guy has some racist and sexist motives behind these murders.
Again. Suspicion, not proof.
Is the mere act of only targeting Asian-descent women at massage parlors not evidence of racism? Yeah he didn't write a manifesto (that we know of) before doing these murders, but damn I feel like this is an awfully high level epistemological standards.
I've read (and I am taking with a grain of salt) that he was seen at those places before/has visited as a patron and it's frankly just as likely this is more specific to targeting sex workers/women than a straight up racism thing. Of course, it can also be a combination of these factors, or we can step back and discuss the myriad of factors why asian women were the majority of workers there, etc. I'm not trying to discount the element race plays into this, at all, but it has also been odd seeing people online parading around a single, likely faked, screenshot as proof not only of this asshole's intent, but also as like the "poster child" for how the media's rhetoric is inspiring violence. I think it's reasonably fair to assume that race was a factor, but was this necessarily motivated by covid-19 coverage, as people claim? I don't know, personally
Edit, just dropping some links as for why doubt the screenshot's authenticity
Fair point, I still don't think DivineChaos was right in dismissing the racial aspect of these murders as baseless suspicions.
Except i didn't mean to dismiss what you said as baseless at all. The fact that mostly Asians died in the attack is an important factor, but just that won't make a hate crime charge stand. And whatever the guy's motivation was, seems like he's playing on that,
There's obviously a rise of sinophobic violence in this country and I don't doubt for a second that racism and sexism are to blame here. That said, there's equal evidence in what you just said that this guy hated massage parlors.
He doesn't hate the women and workers at the parlor, just the idea of the parlor itself.
I don't think that's a very good line of reasoning. By that logic there's also evidence that the guy merely hates shops that are open late, because both of these places where open late.
That's not exactly what I'm saying. Just that if you can make a connection between him targeting women or Asians, you can make a connection with him targeting massage parlors. It's not like he went and shot up a Chinese food restaurant or something. He went after a specific type of business.
Fuck off
No
deleted by creator
Yes
He’s not even saying “reserve judgement on this particular shooting” he’s saying that there’s no proof that the general uptick in anti-Asian violence has anything to do with white supremacy.
There's a point to be made that sinophobia and anti-asian racism is a broader and more mainstream ideology than explicit white supremacism is (with the obvious caveat that it's inherently linked to and derived from the American civic nationalist cult which is itself inextricably tied to white supremacist ideology, even if the way this manifests in a given person may favor one facet over another or even actively seek to hide some facets), but that's not the way to make that point.
This seems like an over-intellectualizing the fact that the US is pushing war propaganda against China right now.
Yes, it can be connected back to white supremacy. But calling the current Sinophobia & anti-Asian racism "white supremacist" provides cover for Sinophobes who no one would consider white supremacists e.g. Ilhan Omar & AOC.
I agree with what you everything you said, though. Just wanted to include this criticism. It applies to everyone in this thread.
Yeah, that's basically my point, I just felt the need to acknowledge that yes, American nationalism is tied to white supremacist ideology even if someone touting it or an offshoot of it may profess anti-racist sentiment or even be in active conflict with the more overtly racist nationalists.
this forum's obsession with trying to dunk on glenn is just as sad/tiresome as glenn's obsession with trying to dunk on whomever (I honestly don't know or care to learn). who gives a shit, you worms.