josefjohann [none/use name]

  • 1 Post
  • 14 Comments
Joined 4 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 26th, 2020

help-circle













  • Exactly. The entire concept of an 'echo chamber' is punishingly stupid. The idea that any community can be classified as an echo chamber based entirely on a broad-brush gloss of its ideological disposition/subject matter of focus ignores so many important indicators for what makes for deep engagement with ideas. There are so many important indicators such as:how broad are the range of interests and media shared by the group, how responsive are people who talk to one another, how many ideas are people able to keep in the air at the same time,how much are people talking to each other in a way where they bare the idiosyncracies of their personality vs. how much they're memeing + chasing clout or engaging in shitposting etc. etc.

    Part of the common values of a community can be its disposition to openness and engagement with new information and ideas, too. They can function as sources of new information and new interactions with people that pull them up out of their stupor of circlejerking and echoing familiar concepts to each other. There's a whole slate of ideas and metrics you would use to analyze whether people are gaining from, or being made more shallow by any given community and the 'echo chamber' concept is thoroughly inadequate to engaging with the question.