I went digging for this and all I could find was a it came from a British POW that told the story for Anthony Beevor's book Berlin: The Downfall 1945, published in 2002.
Funnily enough the edition I found had no mention of the 22 hours and instead stated it was 16. I have no clue where "22 hours" comes from other than where it's stated as such on the website of the (President) Hoover Institution. Please go look at this ghoulish website for a what's what of evil shit. Also, imagine having someone lecture you on economics and they work for the HOOVER Institution lmao
I know Beevor was heavily criticised by Russian historians for repeating "Asiatic horde" myths about the Soviets in looking into this as well.
See, it's definitely fake, I mean what, this brit was around for this? No. Maybe, if he's being "honest," at best heard it at his camp or something.
Otherwise, you have a room full of Soviet soldiers and a now dead SS soldier. Not exactly a crowd that's getting this story out to the English speaking world.
So, it's a lie.
Funny Beevor and the Hoover institute shared it, in a "of course they did" way.
It's amazing how many of these anecdotal stories exist about communists, with no legs to stand on after brief critical engagement. The atrocities of the nazis are known, there's their own records and testimony. The brutality of the Japanese invasion of China, perhaps less records, but plenty of first hand experience. The horrors of colonialism by the west? Same.
You don't see those stories in these memes. Just those scawy weds. It's kind of awesome that even though many socialist states are gone, they still terrify the West. The word Bolshevik, which would mean nothing outside Russia before the revolution, now decades after the collapse still inspires fear. Really shows the power and potency of Marxism, and encouraging that it's enemies fear us so, while fascists are rehabilitated. Pretty clear who's the real threat to hellworld. Naturally their propaganda makes it hard for us, but they wouldn't waste their time on it if they weren't concerned, and the Left throughout history has demonstrated the one thing they can't abide: there is an alternative- another, better world IS possible.
That's a long way to say "burn in hell imaginary doge meme SS guy"
I get you. The guy was a literal SS officer and most probably did 10 times worse to Eastern European civilians on his march there, so fuck him; But it's completely understandable to feel repulsed by how gruesome and cruel a man's execution was, regardless of how much he deserved it.
Whenever I see someone incessantly posting stuff like that they usually get banned after a couple weeks because they show their ass somewhere else so I'm calling it now lol
yeah it's needless and pointlessly cruel. there's a solid case for executing Nazis (although practical concerns around if you execute people who surrender everyone will fight to the death should be considered) but torture's just wrong
The Germans were en masse exterminating millions of people, committing unspeakable crimes against humanity, slaughtering defenseless people. And you deny the wronged revenge?
I mean...I wasn’t there, so I can’t really speak to what I would do.
But ideally they would be treated with compassion, like I think everyone should be.
idk...that still seems kind of messed up
Assuming it's true lol
The source on this shit is always some West German Nazi that was given a position in government by the Americans.
I went digging for this and all I could find was a it came from a British POW that told the story for Anthony Beevor's book Berlin: The Downfall 1945, published in 2002.
Funnily enough the edition I found had no mention of the 22 hours and instead stated it was 16. I have no clue where "22 hours" comes from other than where it's stated as such on the website of the (President) Hoover Institution. Please go look at this ghoulish website for a what's what of evil shit. Also, imagine having someone lecture you on economics and they work for the HOOVER Institution lmao
I know Beevor was heavily criticised by Russian historians for repeating "Asiatic horde" myths about the Soviets in looking into this as well.
See, it's definitely fake, I mean what, this brit was around for this? No. Maybe, if he's being "honest," at best heard it at his camp or something. Otherwise, you have a room full of Soviet soldiers and a now dead SS soldier. Not exactly a crowd that's getting this story out to the English speaking world.
So, it's a lie.
Funny Beevor and the Hoover institute shared it, in a "of course they did" way. It's amazing how many of these anecdotal stories exist about communists, with no legs to stand on after brief critical engagement. The atrocities of the nazis are known, there's their own records and testimony. The brutality of the Japanese invasion of China, perhaps less records, but plenty of first hand experience. The horrors of colonialism by the west? Same.
You don't see those stories in these memes. Just those scawy weds. It's kind of awesome that even though many socialist states are gone, they still terrify the West. The word Bolshevik, which would mean nothing outside Russia before the revolution, now decades after the collapse still inspires fear. Really shows the power and potency of Marxism, and encouraging that it's enemies fear us so, while fascists are rehabilitated. Pretty clear who's the real threat to hellworld. Naturally their propaganda makes it hard for us, but they wouldn't waste their time on it if they weren't concerned, and the Left throughout history has demonstrated the one thing they can't abide: there is an alternative- another, better world IS possible.
That's a long way to say "burn in hell imaginary doge meme SS guy"
a customer at my job was talking to me about economics and mentioned he was watching lectures hosted by the hoover institution lol
Yeah exactly it's definitely faked.
deleted by creator
Fuck that. After what the fascists did to Europe and the Soviet Union, one scum playing the piano for 22 hours is a drop of water in an ocean.
...maybe...but it still makes me uncomfortable.
I get you. The guy was a literal SS officer and most probably did 10 times worse to Eastern European civilians on his march there, so fuck him; But it's completely understandable to feel repulsed by how gruesome and cruel a man's execution was, regardless of how much he deserved it.
I mean it isn’t understandable. The person had no soul. No conscience. They deserved their fate.
Whenever I see someone incessantly posting stuff like that they usually get banned after a couple weeks because they show their ass somewhere else so I'm calling it now lol
You’re calling me as something?
?
Are you accusing me of something, Pez?
Just don’t be a fascist. :shrug-outta-hecks:
It's incredible that you can show such a degree of concern for another human being, and I commend you for it.
...sarcasm?
not this time. I find displays of greater concern than I am capable of inspiring.
deleted by creator
nah, fuck em, I'm glad those comrades allegedly got some entertainment out of that piece of shit and I hope he's still playing piano eternally in hell
I don't know about that 😓
It's pretty messed up, they should have just shot him. Or at least just put him out if his misery like five minutes after he stared playing.
yeah it's needless and pointlessly cruel. there's a solid case for executing Nazis (although practical concerns around if you execute people who surrender everyone will fight to the death should be considered) but torture's just wrong
deleted by creator
Knife work demands finesse.
deleted by creator
here me out though it just encourages them and lets them play themselves up as martyrs
Removed by mod
Removed by mod
Just seems like sadism and revenge to me
The Germans were en masse exterminating millions of people, committing unspeakable crimes against humanity, slaughtering defenseless people. And you deny the wronged revenge?
I mean...I understand the motivation, but I don’t think that makes it good
Well, how would you have treated the people responsible for slaughter of that level?
I mean...I wasn’t there, so I can’t really speak to what I would do.
But ideally they would be treated with compassion, like I think everyone should be.
I don’t think those who commit genocide deserve compassion
I’m probably coming at this from a different angle so that’s okay.
Just shoot them like a normal person