Perhaps someone familiar with Juche ideology can explain this well - I've read that there's a tenet of Juche that states that the Kim family wielding power is essential to revolution. I know this isn't the same thing as a monarchy, but why (if at all) is it justified?
Critical support isn't 'oh this CIA lie is totally based let me explain'. There is no tenet that the Kim family wielding power is essential to the revolution. The position each Kim held so far has been abolished and replaced by a more democratic institution. Kim Il Sung was the President, like in a bourgeois republic he was the head of legislature, government, party and military.
After his death there's no president anymore, its role split between the Premier, Chairman of the Presidium, the Chairman of the National Defence Commission and General Secretary of the Workers' Party of Korea.
Kim Jong Il was Chairman of the National Defence Commission and General Secretary of the Workers' Party of Korea, and now that position doesn't exist anymore, it's been replaced by a more horizontal structure in which nobody has full veto power.
Kim Jong Un is the first secretary of the WPK *and Chairman of the National Defence Commission. Kim Jong Un is head of state, not head of government, he has no role at all in the legislature , and does not have veto power in the Party. His formal powers are, beyond being the leader of the party and a propaganda figurehead, of foreign relations and the military . All these positions are elected.
I believe the idea of critical support comes into play. I think if you removed the idea of the Kim family constantly keeping power it would be more appealing. I honestly plan on migrating there in order to live in a proper communist society. Besides, the Kims are good leaders
They’ve achieved a self sustaining agricultural base, a powerful industrial center, and a first rate defense military.
Have you read any North Korean newspapers recently? All I see are new buildings, fast economic response times, a fight against the pandemic, and a condemnation of Western Imperialism
I really don't mean to be pedantic here but uh, no class does not mean some class. If Juche ideology requires a dynasty to lead revolution, it has inherent class and hierarchy required to enforce that class. I'm happy to hear disagreements or why I'm a fucking dumbass here, but I just don't see it
Perhaps someone familiar with Juche ideology can explain this well - I've read that there's a tenet of Juche that states that the Kim family wielding power is essential to revolution. I know this isn't the same thing as a monarchy, but why (if at all) is it justified?
Wtf is wrong with this thread.
Critical support isn't 'oh this CIA lie is totally based let me explain'. There is no tenet that the Kim family wielding power is essential to the revolution. The position each Kim held so far has been abolished and replaced by a more democratic institution. Kim Il Sung was the President, like in a bourgeois republic he was the head of legislature, government, party and military.
After his death there's no president anymore, its role split between the Premier, Chairman of the Presidium, the Chairman of the National Defence Commission and General Secretary of the Workers' Party of Korea.
Kim Jong Il was Chairman of the National Defence Commission and General Secretary of the Workers' Party of Korea, and now that position doesn't exist anymore, it's been replaced by a more horizontal structure in which nobody has full veto power.
Kim Jong Un is the first secretary of the WPK *and Chairman of the National Defence Commission. Kim Jong Un is head of state, not head of government, he has no role at all in the legislature , and does not have veto power in the Party. His formal powers are, beyond being the leader of the party and a propaganda figurehead, of foreign relations and the military . All these positions are elected.
Good post, op
deleted by creator
I believe the idea of critical support comes into play. I think if you removed the idea of the Kim family constantly keeping power it would be more appealing. I honestly plan on migrating there in order to live in a proper communist society. Besides, the Kims are good leaders
How old are you, if you don’t mind me asking. Feel free to ballpark it to avoid identifying info.
maybe if u got Kim into tf2 it will get an update
I don't need to be convinced on the idea of critical support, I'm just wondering what the justification for this is.
There really isn’t any. But they’re the ideal worker state thougj
deleted by creator
They’ve achieved communism. They’re self sustaining. The citizens are content. There isn’t any political divides in the country
Lol just bc they’re not a capitalist hellscape like the US doesn’t mean they’ve achieved full communism.
They’ve achieved a self sustaining agricultural base, a powerful industrial center, and a first rate defense military.
Have you read any North Korean newspapers recently? All I see are new buildings, fast economic response times, a fight against the pandemic, and a condemnation of Western Imperialism
deleted by creator
Communism, not anarchism
deleted by creator
Read theory.
If you read theory, Bill, you would understand that Juche hierarchy is good ctually
deleted by creator
How is there not?
deleted by creator
Because the country is centrally planned, there is no class, and there is social leftism
what do you mean by social leftism? also doesn't the necessity of the kims leading the revolution sort of preclude the whole "no class" thing?
I disagree with the kims thing but otherwise there is no class or hierarchy
I really don't mean to be pedantic here but uh, no class does not mean some class. If Juche ideology requires a dynasty to lead revolution, it has inherent class and hierarchy required to enforce that class. I'm happy to hear disagreements or why I'm a fucking dumbass here, but I just don't see it
Well, it’s problematic. I agree. But otherwise, there’s nothing really wrong with them being in power
deleted by creator
deleted by creator
Intuitive thought
deleted by creator
deleted by creator
Who are you talking about
deleted by creator
deleted by creator
deleted by creator
deleted by creator
deleted by creator