It was pretty much ALWAYS a farce. During the highest periods "De-kulakization" the average assets seized in their liquidation was only a couple hundred ruble... "Rich Peasants" they were certainly not.
I was under the impression that the reason for Kulaks being treated poorly was that they destroyed ~14 million tons of grain and slaughtered thousands of head of livestock instead of turning it over. If they only got a few hundred rubles, that means they did in fact destroy their food stores.
I guess the closest modern allegory would be slumlords (the wealthiest) and air-bnb renters (the average). Neither of those groups are incredibly wealthy and the later usually sells their labor as well as renting.
Do you have a source for your claim and contextualization how much a few hundred roubles were back then?
Furthermore how much acres were those equivalent to?
Kulaks first as tragedy, then as farce.
It was pretty much ALWAYS a farce. During the highest periods "De-kulakization" the average assets seized in their liquidation was only a couple hundred ruble... "Rich Peasants" they were certainly not.
https://i.imgur.com/4eZw2GQ.jpg
I was under the impression that the reason for Kulaks being treated poorly was that they destroyed ~14 million tons of grain and slaughtered thousands of head of livestock instead of turning it over. If they only got a few hundred rubles, that means they did in fact destroy their food stores.
A good article from the Soviet Encyclopedia.
I guess the closest modern allegory would be slumlords (the wealthiest) and air-bnb renters (the average). Neither of those groups are incredibly wealthy and the later usually sells their labor as well as renting.
Do you have a source for your claim and contextualization how much a few hundred roubles were back then? Furthermore how much acres were those equivalent to?
What happens when Kulaks found a country on Kulakism: Canada