There's loads of stuff I'm interested in, and when I'm reading I do genuinely enjoy it, however every time I earnestly create any reading list it just piles up until I give up.
This pattern has happened with books, movies, tabs, theory, video essays, wikipedia, etc etc.
This happens to me too, for me I recognize it is a bit of Fear of Missing Out.
What helps is having a print copy, and then booking an hour to not have any screens around to just read. Its hard.
Then, I just have to pick a book to start with (also hard), and then not switch books part way through (also hard).
My strategy so far has been to start with short books.