There is absolutely no defensible morality in supporting genocide and land theft. Free Palestine!
enemy of my enemy is my friend
well until they rosa us but hey whatever
social democrats are liberals, only useful fighting fascism then should be immediately gotten rid of
Dsa is more of a big tent of socialist tendencies and succdems, and I think the succdems no longer have a majority coalition on the national committee
Honestly the few cpusa members I know are really big into electoralism and helping democrats
Social democrats are not that useful for fighting fascism most of the time. They side with capital and therefore the fascists.
Nothing is more liberal than uncritical categorization and condemnation.
For every time they were useful there are 3 times where they were harmfuul
Lemme guess, is it DSA? It must be DSA
I'm not defending the SPD, that's what is so sad. You can't tell the difference between someone saying that something is complicated and someone saying that something is good.
Its no different than when libs flatten the entire 70 year history of the Soviet Union into "Stalin Bad". Do you think that being ignorant of history and intentionally avoiding independent thought, let alone immanent critique is a virtue? Have you ever even heard of dialectics?
Welcome to the kick party comrade, get yet shots in
What's the general idea of Broue's that's relevant here? I'm not familiar with them
Pierre Broue wrote the definitive book on the German revolution. Its kind of a doorstop but the events that surrounded the death of Rosa Luxemburg are not black and white. The Vorwarts siege was led by a mob of radical anarchists that was taken over by police infiltrators, not social democrats. You cant compare the SPD to anything anywhere in the world, the SPD was the most powerful party in Germany, they weren't even remotely comparable to DSA. And Rosa was in the SPD, she believed in the party until she was killed by police. People's entire life was contained in the party, it was incredible. But it got fucked up by power and capital. Just because Ebert was a member of the SPD doesn't make all social democrats Ebert. Well, unless someone want to have an excuse to kill leftists and then I guess any justification will do fine. I'm not even a social democrat but I'm in DSA so fuck me
And Rosa was in the SPD, she believed in the party until she was killed by police.
She split with the party well before she was killed.
That's interesting. I don't have that kind depth of knowledge about this. I'm not sure what you mean with events surrounding the death of Luxemburg not being "black and white." The SPD was against the KPD in the Spartacist uprising. They chose to side with the fascist in the Freikorps. Seems pretty straightforward in terms of where people stood, but I only have a general understanding.
If you can go more in depth I'd like to know.
I'm not even a social democrat but I'm in DSA so fuck me
I don't think there's a problem with being in DSA. Is there some controversy here I'm not aware of?
I was responding to
social democrats are liberals, only useful fighting fascism then should be immediately gotten rid of
The SPD was the party of Karl Marx. They had sports clubs, dances, all kinds of social programs, peoples entire social existence was wrapped up in the party. The Germany of the SPD was the Germany that gave gender affirming care to trans people, and opened the first hospital for trans people anywhere ever in history.
It was the vote for war that triggered the events of the German revolution. The KPD was in the SPD before like 1918 or 1919. Yeah they were social democrats, no they weren't principled. This was the party of Karl Kautsky as well. There were inherent contradictions, which people would realize if they took a critical view of actual history instead of repeating whatever some fed YouTuber says about it. Its the black and white uncritical view that is the mark of an online commie cosplayer.
you're not reactionary for being a marxist trying to work within a social democrat party- wait
If you have some patience and good faith, then your IRL organizing will go.much smoother I promise! https://www.marxists.org/archive/broue/1975/germrev/index.html
Are they even good for that? History seems to suggest they aren't
I was worried the DSA would lib out on this. It's a good sign that they stand by anti-imperialism when the rubber hits the road.
Serious question here: how?
Do you have an actual strategy to defeat imperialism at home and stop the genocide in Gaza beyond releasing statements?
The article addresses none of the potential practical solutions but instead focused on addressing Isserman’s accusations and raising awareness about the Palestinian issues.
Long time lurker, first time poster here. I'm working on proposals for my local DSA chapters. What do you WANT us to do? I want to do what we can provided we can keep our members safe. At the same time I'm not interested in running yet another book club. I want to make some sort of material impact...
Ideas:
- printing off stickers to slap on Sabra containers "this product supports genocide"
- looking up Zionist supporters, MIC ghouls or other people of interest in the area and carrying out a protest at their homes. I don't believe general marches do anything, but targeted ones could be effective?
- Doing this: https://hexbear.net/post/956137
- Research businesses in the area that fund Israel or do business with Israel. Create information campaign "this business supports genocide"
What else could we do?
