it worries me how little emphasis is put on pr and international relations. if they dont clean up their act, they will lose momentum and international standing real fking quick. the anti-chinese sentiment is spreading rapidly, especially in critical zones like east and southern africa
This is a major criticism I see from Chinese folks on r/sino. The west is waging a massive propaganda war and the Chinese Government isn't really hitting back. Beijing thinks truth will prevail, but it rarely does in the face of coordinated disinformation.
There's exceptionally little China can do about it though. Aside from dismissing the West's claims as nonsense and lies, anything they publish will simply be counter-dismissed as Chinese gommulist propaganda, topped off with a double helping of sinophobic red scareism.
I think we in the west have a tendency to overestimate and project people's distrust of China onto others with drastically different material conditions. What western imperialist governments find repulsive might be viewed positively or indifferently. For the most part, China's role in Africa is leaps and bounds far less harmful than anything the west ever did since they set foot there. Its regional neighbors depend heavily on it for trade and support. Same applies to South America, and they have plenty of problems of their own with their belligerent neighbor to the north. For the most part, poorer nations are simply content to have China as a beneficial trade partner and care little for their domestic politics as it doesn't affect them.
I know that China is seen generally positively in Africa but there are some places where the public opinion isn't great and other places where there probably isn't much opinion on China at all. I think they are making great strides in Africa materially but propaganda is extremely powerful. The US wants to push anti-china propaganda globally and we are better at it and take its importance more seriously. I just think if you're trying to be a world power and your economy is massive enough to spare the expense, you should invest in a sophisticated global propaganda network.
Yeah. There was something on twitter today about how China has a role in the Nigerian SARS program. I know China does soft power, but they need to be careful.
It may be a problem that they are (somewhat justifiably) afraid of letting creative forces free, and err on the side of caution with censorship. I've seen webnovels get cancelled by authorities where it would be very far-fetched to say they had subversive content.
Chinese propaganda for foreign consumption is all hamfisted too. Not nearly as sophisticated as what VOA or the big European state-run broadcasters put out.
True, I'll watch some CGTN and CCTV videos and it is very obviously state-run propaganda, which is going to turn off most western viewers. China is a massive and rich country, they've gotta be able to get someone who understands how to effectively propagandize westerners. I saw one of those little segments they run in between news shows that's like a commercial for the network and tbh it looked like an SNL skit. The white people had really weird makeup on that made them look like androids and they said something like "I'm an American but I live in China and I'm bringing you the news". Any normal american who saw that would immediately think it was bizarre unless they were like 75.
it worries me how little emphasis is put on pr and international relations. if they dont clean up their act, they will lose momentum and international standing real fking quick. the anti-chinese sentiment is spreading rapidly, especially in critical zones like east and southern africa
deleted by creator
This is a major criticism I see from Chinese folks on r/sino. The west is waging a massive propaganda war and the Chinese Government isn't really hitting back. Beijing thinks truth will prevail, but it rarely does in the face of coordinated disinformation.
There's exceptionally little China can do about it though. Aside from dismissing the West's claims as nonsense and lies, anything they publish will simply be counter-dismissed as Chinese gommulist propaganda, topped off with a double helping of sinophobic red scareism.
I mean I'm sure they can do something, especially in places in the global south.
I think we in the west have a tendency to overestimate and project people's distrust of China onto others with drastically different material conditions. What western imperialist governments find repulsive might be viewed positively or indifferently. For the most part, China's role in Africa is leaps and bounds far less harmful than anything the west ever did since they set foot there. Its regional neighbors depend heavily on it for trade and support. Same applies to South America, and they have plenty of problems of their own with their belligerent neighbor to the north. For the most part, poorer nations are simply content to have China as a beneficial trade partner and care little for their domestic politics as it doesn't affect them.
anything to wean them off the IMF fent is good in my book
I know that China is seen generally positively in Africa but there are some places where the public opinion isn't great and other places where there probably isn't much opinion on China at all. I think they are making great strides in Africa materially but propaganda is extremely powerful. The US wants to push anti-china propaganda globally and we are better at it and take its importance more seriously. I just think if you're trying to be a world power and your economy is massive enough to spare the expense, you should invest in a sophisticated global propaganda network.
Yeah. There was something on twitter today about how China has a role in the Nigerian SARS program. I know China does soft power, but they need to be careful.
They could focus on more subtle influence a la hollywood
You seen Wolf Warrior 2? They still have a lot to learn about implementing film-as-propaganda.
It may be a problem that they are (somewhat justifiably) afraid of letting creative forces free, and err on the side of caution with censorship. I've seen webnovels get cancelled by authorities where it would be very far-fetched to say they had subversive content.
Chinese propaganda for foreign consumption is all hamfisted too. Not nearly as sophisticated as what VOA or the big European state-run broadcasters put out.
True, I'll watch some CGTN and CCTV videos and it is very obviously state-run propaganda, which is going to turn off most western viewers. China is a massive and rich country, they've gotta be able to get someone who understands how to effectively propagandize westerners. I saw one of those little segments they run in between news shows that's like a commercial for the network and tbh it looked like an SNL skit. The white people had really weird makeup on that made them look like androids and they said something like "I'm an American but I live in China and I'm bringing you the news". Any normal american who saw that would immediately think it was bizarre unless they were like 75.
Oh no, they are acting like Democrats
Xi needs to make a twitter account and post
oh god please no
deleted by creator
It makes no difference what China says, absolutely no one would believe them, the propaganda in the west would just step up.
deleted by creator
Any attempt to compete with western propaganda would require such demented levels of dishonesty that it would corrupt their entire system.
deleted by creator
lol as if pr would help them
nothing they actually say or do matters in that regard, they're right not to focus on it
If they are a rival to the US, the US will try to destroy them. How they run their country in no way shape or form changes that fact.