Sad to find out that a lot of vegan comrades would consider me not a leftist and a reactionary, but whatcha gonna do
Disagreements on policy, methods, goals, philosophy, leaders, countries, protests, consumption, rules, etc need to be debated in a civil manner. Purity tests and calling people reactionary over disagreements should be banned as a form of sectarianism. Even though these may not be conveniently labeled as part of pre-existing tendencies, this form of exclusionary discourse still divides the movement in the same way.
i haven't really gotten too much of that vibe from them. i've seen a lot more punching at vegans than i've seen vegans punching.
how about you go in and read any of the replies of the 10 posts about this struggle session on any of the pages?
Yeah, I think maybe we should start quarantining these struggle sessions somehow before they gain traction and snowball to the point that they consume everyone’s experience on the site.
Like three to five posts? Cool maybe I learn something. 100 posts? Cringe
ban anyone who feels the need to start a new one
ban anyone who feels the need to blame individuals for things instead of systems, and parody anyone who doubles down on the idea that individual choice will solve systemic problems
oh look the guy who is following me around and replying to all of my posts
I've literally never replied to one of your comments before I don't know what you're talking about?
you are right, i misread your name as someone else's name. my bad and sincere apology in the instant negative reaction
collective choice is made up of the combined individual choices of many.
that is why we have universal health care, a famously popular policy
yelling at people that we need universal health care has been extremely successful in the USA, let's take that same rhetoric to animal liberation
Here's the thing, if your health and finances allow, you can make the choice to opt out of consuming animal products, not so for universal healthcare.
if your health and finances allow, you can simply purchase your own health care
that's the problem and reinforces why individual choice isn't effective. I hope you see this some day
What? Opting out of healthcare in the US just means I don't have healthcare. There is no critical mass of people opting out of health insurance which will force change. Opting out of consuming animal products, on the other hand, does produce an immediate impact.
a mass movement of people not having healthcare (a strike of sorts) would actually be pretty effective
Except you can't. In my state your employer is mandated to force you into an insurance plan, unless you can prove you are otherwise covered.
hmm so you're saying that individuals making a choice won't do anything, as it takes collective action (as you acknowledge that it would be effective to have an insurance strike)?
I wonder how this relates to individual consumption choices...
Every vegan I know acknowledges that the more people we convert to our philosophy the greater impact we will have. Yet when we do try and convince people to give up animal products we're accused of being "sanctimonious" and forcing our views on others. I really don't understand how leftists can't understand this, if the revolution happened tomorrow and our side won,, how many liberals would we be forcing to conform to a way of life that they vehemently disagree with? Marxism is about the collective good vs the individual and, humanitarian considerations aside, a society devoid of animal products is a net collective good.
being pissed off at friends won't get them on our side.
that's what you're doing here - yelling at people and refusing to acknowledge that it's not about the Individual Choices of the people you are shaming. Shaming just shuts people down and off subjects (as you see by the many non-vegans who are posting threads about how this is triggering things like their fucking eating disorders) instead of bringing them towards wanting to fight for the collective
Someone can eat meat today but stand for and fight for animal liberation. That's what we ultimately want - Animal Liberation even if it doesn't happen tomorrow. I won't be yelling at people who opt to eat meat in the meantime as long as I can continue the fight to get them to agree that Animal Liberation is the correct end goal we all must work towards in regards to animal rights. Their being allies is what brings around the material change
it wouldn't have the amount of popularity its grown to have if people didn't keep yelling
the discourse changed away from yelling which is why it's popular
turns out making people feel guilty about things doesn't inspire them to want to make change, but instead causes them to disengage
it's not individual choice that keeps for profit health care going, of course CEOs and board members of insurance companies aren't going to feel guilty, they're sociopaths.
your comparing apples to plastic bottles.
even if you're talking about revolution and protest it's still made up of individuals making a decision to do so.
you are misreading my arguments, and i'm disengaging from this as it's clear we will not resolve this contradiction in thought
yeah, but enough people haven't individually made the choice to go on general strike, which is the way we actually get there.
and parody anyone who doubles down on the idea that individual choice will solve systemic problems
Uh... Please say this just means make fun of them
I think that the mods just need to be more aggressive about containing this stuff to megathreads. If you create a comm for arguments with other chapos then people who are angry will just not use it.
the megathread is consistently great and filled with great people who are generally disconnected from the rest of the site
i recommend reading that and ignoring most other discourse
i really should read them more, you're right. the megathreads on the old sub were usually great.
Yeah I'd like to thank everyone who called veganism racist for reminding me I could be doing literally anything else
i love how even in a thread deriding the struggle sessions, you people cannot possibly help but bring them up.
it'd be neat if there was discussion but it's mostly just insult flinging.
even in this very thread, people can't fucking help themselves and have brought the struggle session here, too.
just killing time while working, but yeah I should probably do it somewhere else.
Believe it or not there's a whole community for discussing veganism. They just keep posting in other communities.
