Like, the planet is gonna be uninhabitable???
for the people who don't spend their time thinking about politics or economics, the question doesn't even begin to occur to them because they don't have any conception of what "capitalism" is, at least in relation to their current conditions. they cannot see it any more than we can see air or a fish can see water. they are so surrounded by ideology that they aren't even aware that they have an ideology, like how a person with an accent doesn't know they have an accent unless they talk to somebody with a different accent (or are told about it). at best, they might hear that carbon taxes are a thing and are like, yeah, we should do that maybe.
for the people who do spend their time thinking about politics or economics and still like capitalism despite its climatic impact, their connection to these political views are purely vibes based and not informed by any intimate connection to their conditions or the conditions of others, because the average person is so far removed from any kind of political process or having a say in anything that everything is completely unchangeable. There Is No Alternative. they saw a facebook/twitter/discord meme and go along with that due to social pressures, or maybe somebody at their workplace is a conservative or a libertarian or a centrist or even a socialist and they discuss current events and the ideology rubs off on them and they "become" those things without even really knowing what those things are, or the political histories of those movements, or even the names of the titans of those movements. and thus, if you have decided that you are a libertarian because of all these small little things that are, again, completely independent of your material conditions much of the time, then you "join the team" so to speak and get to know the boilerplate arguments and, for lack of a better word, memes, and finding that community slightly alleviates the crippling social atomization you feel at every moment because your job sucks or is unfulfilling, you live in a sprawling suburb where the same house has been copy-pasted a thousand times or a giant apartment complex, and never talk to your neighbours.
at no point are a solid 90-95% of self-described capitalism supporters intimately engaged to the ideas and philosophies that they say they support. few of them are actually going and doing the reading. at most they might listen to a podcast or youtube channel called something like "The Epic Logician" or "The Woke Destroyer" or "Communism Kills, Capitalism Uplifts" or something. it's vibes based. it's a bubble of idealism that is being supported by the 7 or so billion people outside of the imperial core who actually have to live in material reality. it will come crashing down around these people probably within their lifetimes for the ones under 40 as the empire declines, and that'll be the really interesting part - of how 300 million people or so suddenly have to come to terms with material reality rather than imagined fights or "meme wars" online between different political factions.
the final class of people are the ones who prefer capitalism despite its environmental impact and have done a lot of reading, and the vast majority of these people are, simply put, sickos who should be [insert fedposting here]
There Is No Alternative.
Just got in to this with some friends the other day. They all recognize capitalism bad, but we can't do communism, you see, because communism bad. What is communism? Well communism is stalin 1984 big spoon no food, of course. So we have to do Something Else. What else? They don't know, but there must be something. Why has there never been something else that didn't just removed in to capitalism or fascism? They don't know, but there must be Something Else. How are you going to solve the problem that private property ownership tends towards monopoly and property owners will always band up to remove regulations against them? They don't know but there must be Something Else.
We have the fucking solution, we've had it for like 150 years!
the question doesn't even begin to occur to them because they don't have any conception of what "capitalism" is
Yeah I think that's probably right. Speaking with comrades I organize with IRL it's embarrassing how few leftists can confidently describe it.
Most people don't know what capitalism is and therefore cannot assign blame to it.
Capitalism is when trade, therefore always existed. Private property is my toothbrush. People have no clue what Capitalism is and they have no clue what the alternatives actually are.
Basically why people go insane and become Sovereign Citizens.
At some base level, they understand that this is all bullshit. But they'll buy into this theory that there's One Neat Trick to navigate your way out of a miserable existence.
So rather than understanding capitalism as this all encompassing ideological system of captive human labor, they adopt this Cheat Code mentality where anyone sufficiently educated and savvy can win by tapping in the right combo.
At some base level, they understand that this is all bullshit. But they'll buy into this theory that there's One Neat Trick to navigate your way out of a miserable existence.
So rather than understanding capitalism as this all encompassing ideological system of captive human labor, they adopt this Cheat Code mentality where anyone sufficiently educated and savvy can win by tapping in the right combo.
That's the ideological basis and appeal of almost every cryptoscam, too.
Even among those that understand what capitalism is and even why it's bad there's a sizable faction who think it's the best thing we've ever tried or can try.
The best take I saw on this, it’s because too many in the West, and America specifically, assume they’ll be able to buy their way out of the consequences of climate change. They, or their governments, have the money to buy the resources needed to make it a non-issue for them.
So the real tipping point from a political economy perspective is going to be when that resource crunch hits because the places where those resources normally get extracted from become uninhabitable, plus the people fleeing those areas (already starting) cause a migrant crisis that will make the Syrian one look positively microscopic. That’s when the panic will set in and the faith in the status quo will implode.
Someone just asserted to me over on reddit that capitalism will sell people insulated houses with AC. I asked three questions back
-
How will people in places like Missouri and Bangladesh pay for that?
-
Do you that houses cost about 50tons of carbon per?
-
How many tens or hundreds of millions of houses do you think the capitalists will build?
They completely ignored the first two questions and only responded to the third with "as many as it takes".
-
All the economists who keep saying "it makes no sense to do anything right now because advances in technology will make it cheaper to address in the future" get the
Mmm, yes, economists, the people most qualified to know what future technological developments will look like. What, engineers? No, we don’t need to ask those nerds.
Economists have something even better than technical expertise: the future discount rate.
It's hard to point to any one voodoo concept from the trash-heap of orthodox economics that is singularly the most damaging, but that one has got to be a top contender.
There's going to be blood like we've never seen.
the places where those resources normally get extracted from become uninhabitable
I hadn't even considered wet bulb death zones also being important resource extraction regions. Man the late 2020s are going to be spicy.
True. People are used to existing alongside awful atrocities and devastation and being mostly insulated from it if not beneficiaries of it as middle class in the global north. they expect this dynamic to always exist, especially since their propaganda tells them that this hierarchy is natural. the south will no doubt be hit worse, but there very little protecting the affluent as well.
Having just come from yelling at a bunch of climate bloomers, they think we're going to tech our way out with carbon capture and that the US and EU are going to switch to renewables in some way, and we're going to plant trees. They think the system can still save them.
I despise "Hope". Hope is waiting for someone to save you. Hope is not making plans because someone else will figure it out. Hope is sitting back and waiting for death. Hope isn't action, it's not praxis, it's not revolution. It's complacency, and unearned surety that something will magically appear and make everything alright. Hope is for people who have already given up. Hope is for people who see no future. Hope is death.
they think we're going to tech our way out with carbon capture
"We don't have to do anything, the scientists and engineers will work their asses off to solve this problem that we caused by not listening to them in the first place"
It's logic like that that makes me laugh when people call leftists "lazy".
Want to know who's lazy? Comfortable, privileged people in the global north who can't be bothered to think about the consequences of their actions. They're absolute philistines that care for little beyond their own pleasure, and while it's cool that some people to innovate solutions. It gets these smuglords to point and say "see, they will clean up after me! Now let me consooooooom in peace!"
More and more I ask libs this question and usually their answer is "economic systems have nothing to do with climate change." Basically they think climate change is inevitable and it doesn't matter how humanity approaches economics, it was always gonna happen. They then usually say dumb shit like "capitalism invented solar panels!" As if communist nations don't have any reason to solve climate change because the only reason to solve a problem is profit incentive.
I actually ran into this recently. Something about how my 'economic' politics weren't addressing the actual issues. I about choked.
Yeah it sucks but what are you gonna do? I have a mortgage to pay and kids to feed. All I hear is that people are driving too much and eating too many burgers, and look, I could cancel that trip to Cancun and skip the one week I get away from the grind every year, but everyone else is still going so it's not like what I do is going to make a big difference either way. I ordered that impossible burger at a BK the other day, even. The kids are pretty bright - hey, look, Timmy got an A in freakin' calculus last semester - they'll figure something out, and I'll be dust by then anyways the way my heart's been going.
Almost like you can’t expect individuals to solve systemic problems 🤔
True facts, and I think the main reason for the West's complete failure of imagination around addressing climate change through policy. We had a whole unit on nudge theory in a policy class that I took because anything more involved than redesigning a form is A u T h O r I t A r I a N i S m. It's to the point where the Heritage Foundation's own idea for carbon markets is now considered a lefty pipe dream.
"Authoritarianism" is such a bizarre, brain rotting cliche. Bedtime? Authoritarianism. Changing your nappies? Authoritarianism! Forcing people at gun-point to not destroy the world and all life upon it? Red fash tankie evil gommunism authoritarianism!:?!>?!!!!!!#@4hyg u89-ip1rhj9-23ehf214
Ironic because it's the climate crisis that undid my fear of communism in the first place.
"Wait, so everyone is tacitly okay with pollution but nazism came back as a totally grassroots movement? Ok, maybe authoritarianism isn't so bad after all...."
I think it is a combination of several factors. One is the triumph of the end of history myth in the imperial core. A lot of history has happened but the lack of an anticapitalist left wing and the onslaught of reactionary propanda for the last few decades has made capitalism feel like an unchangeable law of nature to many people. There is no alternative, and thinking capitalism is good or bad is as pointless as having opinions on gravity.
Another factor is that climate change is too big and horrible to comprehend. There's nothing you can do about it as an individual and the individual nation states that people comprehend politics inside of are also powerless to do anything but mitigating symptoms. All available data suggests that we're not only heading towards a slow-rolling cataclysm of biblical proportions, those in power will also actively prevent any meaningful action from being taken. You can stare into that abyss and go mad or you can protect your sanity and close your eyes.
That tendency to shy away from facts is helped along by climate denial. We both have the hard chuddy version where climate change is a hoax invented by China because they're envious of America being great. And then there is the soft neoliberal climate denial where you claim to "believe the science" but also claim that it can all be solved by giving tax credits for buying Teslas and believing that a wizard will save us in the form of technology. Both types of climate denial helps make the crisis look less alarming and makes it easy to trick yourself into believing everything will be alright.
Looking the other way is still possible in the imperial core as people there, especially the more privileged members of these societies are still mostly protected against the consequences. For people in the global south climate change means starvation and being driven from their homes while people in the imperial core experience climate change as their lawns turning brown for a few weeks in the summer.
Looking the other way is still possible in the imperial core as people there, especially the more privileged members of these societies are still mostly protected against the consequences.
We thought that until huge swaths of the US south approached very dangerous wet bulb temperatures this summer. With Texas' power grid and the US's decaying infrastructure that's a nightmare that could go off any time.
When libs say "better dead than red," they mean it. They're a death cult so enamored with capitalism that they would rather die under it than live decent lives under its main competitor.
Which, mind you, they can not define and know absolutely nothing about since the USSR barely even exists in pop culture anymore. Terrified of a boogieman that's been dead for 30 years whose face they've never seen.
“Human-caused climate change” and “the anthropocene” do a lot of lifting, as if Elon Musk and a random homeless child are equally responsible for annihilating human civilization.
Even as a kid, I hated those people. Why are they so okay with it? Do they not even like spending time outside?
People just learn to repress things . Like sometimes if you have trauma or anxiety you can become hyper-aware of the dangers and horror in life to the point you basically can’t function anymore (at least this was my experience with ptsd). It’s not like those dangers don’t also exist for people who are well, they do but they just don’t register them, they repress them because they don’t believe that the threat exists for them personally, even if they are aware of it in general. And this is genuinely a healthy and normal way of engaging with life. So it’s natural and convenient to extend that kind of repression to something like climate change too, especially when that perspective is also tacitly supported by the belief systems of ideology, which is a foundational aspect of one’s psychology. For most people it’s a simple task to repress anything that would threaten their fundamental identity. We see what we want to see, unless something forces us to do otherwise. This is why the middle class is one of the more ingenious inventions of capitalism, because people who are materially comfortable will naturally avert and even defend themselves from recognising the realities of the system.
Like sometimes if you have trauma or anxiety you can become hyper-aware of the dangers and horror in life to the point you basically can’t function anymore
Hahahaha yeah... How am I supposed to want to get a job when the capitalists are burning the planet down, y'know?
I honestly think we're the weird ones for realizing and freaking out so much
I feel like it's normal for people's brains to adapt, ignore, and put up walls so that they can remain happy and continue on with their lives regularly
Socialism will
-
Make you hate the country you live in
-
Make you terrified of global warming ("Climate change" was an absolute propaganda coup)
-
Make you wear a mask even though Covid is over
-
Make you suspect Krav Mazov fucked you over personally
-
Most Americans think capitalism is just another word for a barter system.
to most people "looking at what's happening with the global climate" means closing your eyes and vaguely remembering feeling like you probably read a bunch of articles about how green capitalism has all of that covered