- cross-posted to:
- main
There was nothing Obama could've done to push through Garland, it was totally up to McConnell. The real reason they are controlled opposition is because you can bet your ass that no democratic senate majority leader would EVER think of doing that under a Republican president.
inb4 Joe Manchin says "we have to respect Mr. Trump's ability to nominate a justice" and votes for the ghoul
They're gonna shoot down his first choice for not being goulish enough.
My best case scenario is the military realizing it'd be popular for them to "Free us from Trump" and thus coup freeing us liberal's normalcy.
inb4 Joe Manchin says “we have to respect Mr. Trump’s ability to nominate a justice” and votes for the ghoul
"Look, I know some in my party have some issues with the Hon. Judge Jeannine Pirro. But"
Clearly it's going to be Jeanine Áñez, why do think she stepped down?
Juan Guaido. And Trump is going to call him Juan Guido in his victory lap speech.
I don’t think there’s anything they can do to stop a Trump nominee even if they wanted to.
Great, now I'm picturing Obama doing a Baathist-style purge against the Republican Party.
"Uhhh, stand over here." [points to a wall riddled with bullet holes]
Ah yes the FDR move that modern liberals call “his darkest moment”
Obama is a shitlib, him doing nothing is the best we can hope for
Thanks for not retiring in 2013 you stupid selfish fucking bitch. The entire Clintonite democrat establishment, which she was absolutely a part of, are maybe the most selfishly hubristic fucking pricks in American history, with catastrophic consequences. Fucking amazing shit.
*Pulls up r/politics out of morbid curiosity... *
First comment:
Have her tested for polonium poisoning. Not joking. It may be the case that her cancer was “accelerated”. Straight out of the Putin playbook.
L M F A O
we're fucked lmao
women, you've had a nice run, and it was nice knowing you.
Arrogance. Should have stepped down in 2012, doomed us all.
personally, i will love getting to see my rights stripped away from me by mega justice cotton.
Oh please, women haven't been able to get an abortion in most states in the US to begin with.
The repeal of roe v wade has implications far beyond abortion. It would enable the government to politicize every single medical treatment out there. Transgender related healthcare would become totally illegal.
Roe v. Wade simply covered the right to an abortion in all 50 states. If it were repealed, it would become an idiot states' rights issue again. It doesn't mean that trans-related healthcare would become illegal. It would again be a state by state quagmire.
No Roe v Wade wasnt actually about abortion technically speaking. It was about the right to medical privacy, which enables that any thing that's considered safe to do medically related is legal.
The removal of medical privacy enables the government to legislate what happens between a patient and a doctor whereas before that was considered private.
That’s not how this works. Roe v Wade isn’t a law that’s either valid or not, and if its "overturned" that doesn’t mean nobody could cite it. The right to medical privacy would still be there unless the supremes wrote a decision literally saying that the concept of medical privacy was incorrectly inferred from the constitution. And if they’re willing to do that, and states are willing to ban HRT, then it doesn’t matter if they ban abortion or HRT first.
A court decision only has power as precedent in other court cases. And all that means is if a court ignores it you might be able to convince a higher court that they shouldn’t have and that they should grant an appeal. It prevents the government from making laws only to the extent that a legislator doesn’t want to start a court case.
Really the argument is that a court system willing to ban abortion would also be willing to restrict other rights. But abortion doesn’t really function as much of a foot in the door here, it’s just the thing they’re loudest about. If they win they’d have time to do other things, I guess.
Who told you that? It's literally about abortion. They just used "right to privacy" as the legal mechanism for it. It was explicitly about abortion.
If that legal mechanism becomes no longer valid with regard to abortion then its validity with numerous other procedures and acts can be brought into question, no?
Exactly. So blue states allow abortion and red states ban it, which does not create enough pressure in the system to start a meltdown and eventual balkanization like I think a national ban would. And because republicans are ruthlessly smart, they'll never actually push to ban it nationally.
No. If they make an argument based on the life and rights of the fetus and win, then its no longer a state by state issue. Any abortion anywhere would be a violation of that fetus's right to life, so with a stacked court, conservatives could just full send it and ban abortions in all 50 states regardless of circumstances. This is the reason why red states have been passing bans on abortion even in cases of rape or incest (which most Republicans think is too harsh), because you can't make the right to life argument they while also making exceptions. They're trying to agitate the courts and see if they can get a Supreme Court ruling in their favor.
of course. fem-aligned health concerns have always been a disaster because the patriarchy hates us but now, my main fear (in addition to the climate collapsing and the slaughtering immigrants) is biden gets elected, lasts 4 years, and then someone tucker carlson-esque gets elected and we all get returned to the kitchen. repubs have been chomping away at the voting rights act for so long and democrats have just sorta fucking let them
This is an important point that i wasnt thinking about when i was having my initial freakout. Thank you for reminding me
I think this will happen on a much more accelerated timespan at the state level, while the feds will struggle to force liberal states to abandon the protections they have. The chuds aren't going to wait four years once the door is opened.
I mean I think it's a liberal fantasy to live in the Handmaid's Tale, and I doubt that kind of shit is going to happen.
i wasnt thinking of the handmaid's tale? but there are plenty of real life examples of theocratic repression in this country, and it will get worse.
I don't know why you'd assume women are getting returned to the kitchen. We have a lot of stupid fucking regressive laws but the Supreme Court has had very little impact on that.
the "returned to the kitchen" remark was kinda tongue in cheek, but anyway (maybe im not wording this right) but this is another step towards fascism. we're not there yet, but letting right wing psychos more access to controlling the shape of the law will be very bad. this will influence culture and strengthen the already incredible grip of the right.
This isn't good news but the Supreme Court can be countered in a number of ways. There are bellwethers of fascism in this country, but this is not one. It's not great but there's a lot of ways it can be fought entirely within the system.
Oh sure as a woman living in Mississippi I'm sure one would already have such free and easy access.
We all got your joke. The point is women comrades; legit, actual not-lib leftist women are scared as shit, dude.
In fact, women who are libs are still humans too, who will have their rights threatened by this.
Yeah of course. You wouldn't know it here though with all the "good thing that dumb bitch is dead" posts on main.
Yeah it's honestly gross. I don't give a fuck about RBG but this is materially bad for a lot of women.
Leftism is when I make edgy sexist jokes and the more edgy sexist jokes I make the more leftist it is
fuck your parody when it's harmful to your allies and can easily be mistaken as unironic
Hey, I know you tried to just make a joke and it blew up on you. It sucks, I know. Just understand that it happens to all of us. Understand that people who are upset are just trying to tell you how they feel (and they're all probably really on edge right now) and ride the wave. It comes down.
Good. Now Trump can appoint someone. The libs won't have any supreme court seats to shame people over to vote Biden over, Biden will hopefully tank and increasing the liberals will realize the institutional processes have failed them and they can either accept what comes as a result and lie down and take it or accept the system needs changes.
The sooner you realize America is fucked and has been fucked for a while court or no court the sooner you accept these things as necessary to awake the sleepy liberals from their lazy stupor. Only once they've accepted the institutions are lost, that there is nothing sacred left to defend. Then we can see real change. Maybe not revolutionary but certainly we'll be seeing new comrades and maybe you lesser evilism folks might even get an angry enough coalition to get that vaunted harm reduction you're always on about.
This is more wishful thinking than thinking that they'll wait to appoint a new justice after the election.
How is it wishful thinking? Meaningless accusation given how many people sitting on this very website were liberals until Trump broke their brains when he was elected. It works. Liberal trust in institutions has been weakened by Trump's term. Turning the supreme court completely against them due to what they see as an illegitimately elected president while further shatter their belief in the institutions and America itself. Yes it won't work for all of them obviously but it may get enough thinking. They won't be able to run from the horrors now, they won't be able to put the Trump administration away and pretend all is back to normal and they're safe with their Obama body pillow.
America must be weakened internally. Furthering the splits, furthering the antagonisms, the contradictions will accomplish this.
Biden won't tank because of this shit, he'd increase his election chances. This is the WORST THING that could fucking happen to Trump's chances right now. They appoint a justice, there's no incentive to drive his dipshits to the polls, but the Dems have every reason to try to change the way the Supreme Court works and sweep the Senate and the Presidency.
I get you really want this to happen but you have blinders on.
Also the kind of "good, let things get a lot worse so the libs see how bad it is" takes always kinda scare me. Like, please realise that it's always the lower wage working class that disproportionately bare the brunt of this shit
Well I think what we can do is try and point out those contradictions in a way that resonates with the working class that is most affected by them. And believe me, this excellerationist stuff does not resonate. And, like you say organise community support. Show people that an alternative exists and is materially better for them. I think we should at least try to project a hopeful image of the future we want and try to make people believe that more is possible
Uh I hate to tell you this but uh communists in America are in no way a significant enough force to accelerate or otherwise change how things are going.
And how do you think you are going to get a socialist movement in America? The most privileged, propagandized to center of the imperial core? I mean fuck don't make me laugh. You think you'll do it by gradually attacking liberals while Biden's in office? Trump getting elected did more to grow the left than the last 20 years of politics as normal. I won't lie, Bernie was an essential ingredient in that but he's no longer necessary.
Anyways, hell for who? It's already hell for people of color, for women in red states, and for the billions of people worldwide under the US/NATO/Western imperialist boot. You are in the belly of the beast. Try telling Syrians or Libyans or Yemenis or Iraqis that things aren't hell or that this is going to make you sad, tell the mothers of the dead children that you're super worried about this. You're the delusional one if you think business as normal with liberals plodding along ignorantly, half asleep because of Biden and intact institutions they can believe in is going to magically lead to better conditions for growth of socialism in the US or better conditions for people in the US or globally. The US is in decay, it is getting violent. You have Cold War 2.0, Red Scare 3.0 on your hands, the Dems are all on board, lets all attack China, stop the communist party of China, etc. The crazed Trump people? They aren't going back in the box because a Democrat wins. Qanon nutters? They're not going back in the box because a Democrat wins. The Democrats are going to continue to compromise. You need big things to shock the people awake, to get the liberals to pay attention and understand this is not just a Trump thing, that orange man going away will not fix things.
But this website is full of privileged, white Americans. So I am not surprised.
And again as I've said before, if you think the Supreme Court and control of it is going to have any kind of role in whether full blown fascism unfurls here you are ignorant and need to read more. That's incredibly smooth-brained. What it is important as, is a symbol. And the more people who reject its legitimacy within the US the better. The more people who see the US government as illegitimate the better. There is a fairly decent chance we see a second civil war, a balkanization or attempt at it in the coming decades.
Embrace the fear. You can flee if you want but if you're not fleeing don't act like you're going to influence what happens next, don't sit on the edge of your seat hoping bourgeois pawn with a D next to their name will save you, they won't! Give up the liberal breathlessness at the precious liberal institutions being corrupted. You'll feel better mentally.
To quote Gramsci "The old world is dying and the new world struggles to be born; now is the time of monsters".
I'm not saying you have to be happy about it. And some fear is understandable, there are bad times ahead but there would have been if she'd lived another 20 years. But try and understand the larger breakdown of capitalism, the crisis occurring right now and what all that means and what we need to happen to punch through the propaganda.
I can only imagine. Just know that there are a lot of us that care about you and will fight to protect your rights as a human being. We're here for you, comrade!
Yeah, it's going to have to be real dark before the lanyards truly suffer. It's a common fantasy around here.
I mean, I understand where the sentiment comes from, but damn
Judicial appointments are a far greater motivation for conservatives than liberals. “Evil activist judges” is a talking point drilled into their heads for decades, having deep resentment over Roe v Wade and Obergefell. There just isn’t the same energetic resentment in Democrats, they’re not nearly as attuned to the importance of judicial appointments. So the winning move is for the GOP to delay the nomination until after the election to juice Republican turnout, and I honestly think it will work.
I mean, depends, I think the Dems have a pretty good cudgel themselves. This would help both sides a great deal. The GOP may not wait, but it's a good idea for them to.
I think the republicans are immediately going to put up a nominee but people like lisa murkowski i think i have said they won't confirm a new justice this year. either way both sides are going to go furious into 'call your senator' mode which will probably end up making the turnout in nov insane on both sides.
I totally forgot about Murkowski, and Romney's also been getting off on being an anti-Trump Republican so I think you're right, they won't have the numbers.
Oh I admit that was a bit of a hope on my part regarding Biden (I would just find it more amusing if he lost and I think Trump is better for the rise of socialism as he is weakening US imperialism with his ignorance) I admit it may not weaken him but it brings joy and mirth to be to think of liberals being unable to use it as a point of shame with the more skeptical Bernie-liberal types and their frustration is amusing.
As to it depressing Republican turn-out. I don't think so. The people who most care about that are Evangelicals and they are going to turn out maximally for him after he's successfully taken the court for them because they will be celebrating in the hope Roe v Wade will soon be dead. If it had happened last year, yeah maybe, but the excited high of totally controlling the court for the next few decades is going to drive them out. Anyways they're kind of beyond needing the court issue. Evangelicals are deeply fascistic and love Trump just for playing the strongman. You're frankly ignorant of Republican intra-party politics if you think this will depress their turn-out. Trust me when I say the Republicans who care about the court are pretty reliable voters, they vote in off-years as well.
You have blinders on. You strike me as fearful because you genuinely and ignorantly believe the US can be saved or turned "progressive". That it isn't an evil empire that always has been but which has decayed to the point the internal liberal peace is breaking down. This is a matter of not merely social conditions but material.
You have blinders on. You strike me as fearful because you genuinely and ignorantly believe the US can be saved or turned “progressive”.
lmao
Just because I don't think that things will turn out the way you think doesn't make me a liberal. Jesus.
That's not a strong denial but okay.
What about my take do you disagree with? I already said the Biden losing was more a hope than a prediction. Do you honestly think there is a strong case that Biden winning is better for socialism and class consciousness development within the US? Do you seriously think there is a case that Biden winning would result in better decline of US power and reach as an empire?
Notice I don't claim to know what will happen exactly. The strong predictive power of scientific socialism is limited to macro level developments. I'm simply hypothesizing along likely lines and developments. My number one goal is the weakening of US hegemony. I think that is a necessary requisite for socialism anywhere and eventual communism.
That’s not a strong denial but okay.
I'm not a liberal and you're being an asshole about it. I don't feel like talking to someone who's being an asshole.
I mean, I see it kinda like Christianity.
As I am the only true leftist on this website, clearly everyone else here is liberals, but if you strive to be like me in word, deed and thought then while you won't ever be a leftist like me, you can grow to be less of a lib.
In imitating my "only true leftist" bit and calling everyone who disagrees with them a :LIB: @darkcalling approaches true leftism. By speaking against this bit you have sinned and risk me thinking you're less cool.
My current policy is if I think you're super cool after your account gets banned I might try to doxx you and message you about being friends IRL.
I'm working up to the bit where I get my account temp banned for three days before logging off semi-permanently and after that I might relax my standards for IRL meetups a bit. IDK tho.
What if the outcome is more along the lines of 1930-1940 Germany, where the Right obliterates the country forcing the left to flee or die? And only decades from now, does the US recover as a progressive nation.
Yea but if we continue collapsing for the next 10 years, things can get a LOT worse. And only be able to rebuild after losing a major war. Maybe China bombs us...
Inshallah
lol, I want Xi to dress up as Truman and be all, "iT wAs NeCeSsArY", "aCtUaLlY iT sAvEd AmErIcAn LiVeS", and "WhEn YoU hAvE tO dEaL wItH a BeAsT yOu HaVe To TrEaT hIm As A bEaSt”
"Progressive" is a meaningless liberal term.
The US will not have real proletarian solidarity and real socialist/revolutionary potential until substantial changes. As the heart of the empire, many would argue you're doomed to fascism due to material abundance and comfort created by imperialist exploitation of the global south. The truth is fascist social potential has been building in the US for some time. Trump took it out of the box further than anyone and it is not going to be put back in. As I see it Biden being elected puts things off, nothing more. The Republicans are going to elect an open fascist with a functioning brain and less skittishness about imperialism than Trump the next election or the one after. If the left has not made substantial gains, if liberals are convinced the system is not in free fall, that it can be repaired everyone not a reactionary is going to be in some real trouble.
You are frankly ill informed if you think the make-up of the Supreme Court will make or break the fascist moment in the US. Fascism is a result of capitalism defending itself when contradictions have risen too high. It partners with reactionary social thought which the US is already rife on. The US is quite ready to be fascist, the capitalists just need to flick the switch once too many emergency lights start blinking. Presidents have defied them before and they often go out of their way to avoid answering constitutional violations in moments of crisis (think 9/11) even if they do happen to strongly believe it is wrong because they have no standing army or enforcers, the second the president says no their illusion of power crumbles and the respect for the institution with it.
The best scenario for the US as far as advancing communism world-wide is for it to balkanize and break apart. This will be messy but the people in the US are too comfortable and too brainwashed for socialist revolution to occur there anytime but after every other country has already fallen.
The best scenario for the US as far as advancing communism world-wide...
What about the best case scenario overall?
You realize that the election probably means absolutely nothing now right? The supreme court is just going to rule it in favor of Trump just like they did with Bush in 2000 even though if the recount had happened, Gore would've won.
So the Supreme Court is packed with conservatives for decades, the supposed "left" nominee for President is a demented old fool with a history of voting for right-wing policy positions, cops continue to execute people in the streets without consequences, climate change will continue to cause more and more weather disasters until we're all dead, and a deadly virus is spreading around America out of control. We truly live in a hell world.
Hahahaha fuck me I just realized this means a Trump appointee will be in the court when they judge whatever coke-addled election fraud scheme the Republicans are going with.
maybe a sign of a healthy democracy is not one where it hinges on an 87 year old with cancer surviving until mid january
in this comment chain we speculate what ghoul is going to be forced through in the next five hours by some never-before-seen fuckery
my vote's on a franken-creature made from bits of Kissinger and some corpse parts of Alexander Stephens
Because 2020, my guess is that they stage a fake nomination of a fire-breathing conservative and quietly tell some vulnerable swing state senators to vote them down and demonstrate how moderate they are, with the intention of ramming through the person they really want immediately after the election. Then Trump narrowly loses the election and says "fuck it, I'm nominating Tiffany" in his concession speech. McConnell is forced to go along with it because she's better than whoever Biden would pick.
Hey at least a few libs will radicalize, although many more will actually truly go insane
Yeah but will it be enough to help? That's what people said when Trump won
And I mean, yeah there are some who did (God knows there are plenty of ex
and currentlibs on here) but so far our numbers are still far short of where they need to beof course it won't be enough, nothing will be enough until it is. the story of being a leftist is losing all the time every time until you don't and every additional person radicalized in hell is a good thing
I just posted she should have retired under Obama. Waiting for results.
I did that 15 minutes ago and now have 4-5 angry messages from liberals about respecting the dead and them wishing death on 3rd party voters.
more chuds will energize; slavering after the idea of a 6-3 court for then next 10 years.
And what would we have to look forward too if Biden does win? replacing her with Garland, someone deliberately chosen because of their republican-leaning/centrist opinions?
Liberals aren't a class. There are shit loads of working class liberals.
I was a lib once. Still am, but I used to, too.
The past few years of crisis after crisis are what drove me to actually read liberal philosophy. To find the roots of this country or some shit like that. I read that stuff and came to the conclusion that this woo woo feel good virtue shit isn't going to cut it. Then I started reading Marxists.
